Coming soon - Get a detailed view of why an account is flagged as spam!
view details

r/WhatIfFiction

7,383 subscribers
Hypothetical questions with less hypothetical answers

Notice: This subreddit is not actively monitored, so the posts here are only a small subset of what exists on reddit.

Browse by flair

Cursed Magi Protect your Right to Arm Bears TVA Analyst
New Top (24hr) Top (Week) Top (Month)
to r/WhatIfFiction by SegaGuy1983
10 months ago
[Star Wars] What if Anakin lost the pod race in Episode I?
in Star Wars
to r/WhatIfFiction by Vote_for_Knife_Party
6 months ago
[Subreddit Business] Imminent Shutdown of Uncertain Duration
in Subreddit Business
to r/WhatIfFiction by SegaGuy1983
1 year ago
[The Boys/Garfield] What if Homelander was Garfield’s owner?
in The Boys/Garfield
to r/WhatIfFiction by SegaGuy1983
1 year ago
[General] The antagonist in your favorite piece of fiction wins. What’s the biggest effect it has on that world?
in General
to r/WhatIfFiction by SegaGuy1983
1 year ago
[Lord of the Rings trilogy] [General] The cast of the last TV show you watched replaces the Fellowship. Do they successfully destroy the ring?
in General
to r/WhatIfFiction by SegaGuy1983
1 year ago
[Die Hard / Mission Impossible] What if Ethan Hunt was at Nakatomi instead of John McClane?
in Die Hard / Mission Impossible
to r/WhatIfFiction by SegaGuy1983
1 year ago
[DC/Fallout 4] What if Joker was frozen and woke up after the great war?
to r/WhatIfFiction by Totalwink
3 months ago
[DC/Marvel] What if, in the process of becoming the Batman, Bruce took the Super Soldier Serum?
in DC/Marvel
to r/WhatIfFiction by ohmmyzaza
3 months ago
[DC] What if Abin Sur Pod has crash land on Hal Jordan plane & Killed Hal by Accident?Who would be Abin Sur's Successor if Hal died?
in DMV/DC/NOVA
to r/WhatIfFiction by ShareAnxious
3 months ago
[Steven Universe\MCU] What if Gem Homeworld existed in the MCU
to r/WhatIfFiction by patsfan1983
1 year ago
[Die Hard / The Boys] What if Vought International existed during the attack on Nakatomi Plaza?
in Die Hard / The Boys
to r/WhatIfFiction by Throwawaybastard2422
3 months ago
[Star Wars] What if Maul secretly contacted the jedi order and willingly offered to tell them everything about the Sith and the grand plan in exchange for immunity form prosecution so he can retire from being a Sith?
in Star Wars
to r/WhatIfFiction by Dragonball_Z137
3 months ago
[Fullmetal Alchemist] What if Alphonse’s armor body was made of automail?
in fullmetal Alchemist
to r/WhatIfFiction by KillTheBatman2475
3 months ago
[The Matrix] What If Agent Smith Didn't Become A Villain Again In The Sequels?
in The Matrix
to r/WhatIfFiction by mack2028
6 months ago
[scp-3166/lasagna cat] requesting experimental log.
to r/WhatIfFiction by res30stupid
3 months ago
[Aladdin] What if the Genie kept his phenomenal cosmic powers when he was freed from the lamp?
in Aladdin
to r/WhatIfFiction by PJ-The-Awesome
3 months ago
[DC] What if Superman had the mindset of the Punisher?
in DMV/DC/NOVA
to r/WhatIfFiction by res30stupid
3 months ago
[Spider-Man] What if people found out about Peter's mutations from the spider bite *before* he became Spider-Man?
to r/WhatIfFiction by ardouronerous
3 months ago
[HP / X-Men] What if Harry Potter was found by Professor Xavier?
to r/WhatIfFiction by LordAdrianRichter
3 months ago
[MCU] When Tony Stark snaps the Infinity Gauntlet, the power of the Stones is too much for him and kills him. But what if, the Space, Reality, Soul, Mind, and Time Stones sent Tony's consciousness back in time and he woke up in 2012 after having sent the nuke to Chitauri space?
in MCU
to r/WhatIfFiction by curvysquares
3 months ago
[MCU/ Pixar] What if Nick Fury called the Incredibles to fight Loki instead of the Avengers?
in MCU/ Pixar
to r/WhatIfFiction by Leighgion
3 months ago
[DC] What If… Billy Batson turned into Carol Danvers when he said, “Shazam?”
in DMV/DC/NOVA
to r/WhatIfFiction by Tyranid457TheSecond1
3 months ago
[Harry Potter] What if Umbridge was good?
in Harry Potter
to r/WhatIfFiction by KingWilliamVI
3 months ago
[Incredibles\Megamind] How Megamind and Metroman react to supers being made illegal?
to r/WhatIfFiction by ardouronerous
3 months ago
[DC / HP] What if Harry Potter was raised by Bruce Wayne?
in DC / HP