r/FirstTimeStories

7,412 subscribers

Notice: This subreddit is not actively monitored, so the posts here are only a small subset of what exists on reddit.

Browse by flair

F/M M/F F/M/M F M/M M/F/F M/M/F F/F deflowered (f) F/F/M M/T

Showing posts with M/M flair to r/FirstTimeStories

remove filter

Sort by: New Top

to r/FirstTimeStories by Open_Minded_1001

2 months ago

At the seaside - my first cock

M/M

Posted by Open_Minded_1001

Account Strength

50%

Account Age

3 months

Verified Email

Yes

Verified Flair

Total Karma

481

Link Karma

328

Comment Karma

153

Profile updated: 3 days ago

Posts updated: 1 month ago

to r/FirstTimeStories

3 months ago

to r/FirstTimeStories by AndrewParker69

1 month ago

First Gay Experience

M/M

Posted by AndrewParker69

Account Strength

50%

Account Age

8 months

Verified Email

Yes

Verified Flair

Total Karma

321

Link Karma

104

Comment Karma

217

Profile updated: 1 week ago

Posts updated: 2 weeks ago

to r/FirstTimeStories

3 months ago

to r/FirstTimeStories by Horror-Tale-5689

4 months ago

First time sucking

M/M

Posted by Horror-Tale-5689

Account Strength

50%

Account Age

6 months

Verified Email

Yes

Verified Flair

Total Karma

257

Link Karma

Comment Karma

214

Profile updated: 5 days ago

Posts updated: 4 months ago

to r/FirstTimeStories

6 months ago

to r/FirstTimeStories by Final_Juggernaut_572

2 months ago

First time having sex

M/M

Posted by Final_Juggernaut_572

Account Strength

10%

Account Age

8 months

Verified Email

Verified Flair

Total Karma

484

Link Karma

409

Comment Karma

Profile updated: 4 days ago

Posts updated: 1 day ago

to r/FirstTimeStories

8 months ago