Logan (Wolverine) is often considered a better character than Scott Summers (Cyclops) for several reasons rooted in their personalities, backstories, and the roles they play within the X-Men universe:

1. Complexity and Depth: Logan is a deeply complex character with a rich and tragic backstory that spans over a century. His long life filled with loss, trauma, and a constant struggle with his animalistic nature make him a compelling anti-hero. His flaws, such as his temper, self-destructive tendencies, and inner battles, make him relatable and human despite his mutant abilities.

2. Anti-Hero Appeal: Logan embodies the archetype of the anti-hero. He doesn’t fit the mold of a traditional superhero and often operates in morally gray areas. This unpredictability makes him fascinating to follow, as he frequently toes the line between heroism and brutality, giving him an edge that Scott lacks.

3. Redemption Arc: Logan’s journey is one of redemption, constantly battling his darker impulses to do the right thing. His struggle with his violent nature, efforts to atone for his past, and his eventual evolution into a mentor and protector give his character a satisfying, ever-evolving arc that resonates with many fans.

4. Individuality and Rebellion: Logan’s defiance of authority and his preference for doing things his own way contrast sharply with Scott’s often rigid and rule-following nature. Logan’s rebellious streak and independence make him relatable to those who question the status quo, while Scott often represents the establishment.

5. Charisma and Raw Emotion: Logan’s gruff demeanor, sharp wit, and raw emotional depth make him a standout character. He’s often more charismatic in his rugged, no-nonsense way than Scott, whose straight-laced, often stoic leadership style can come across as rigid or dull.

6. Relatable Flaws: Logan’s flaws are visible and relatable. His constant battle with anger, loneliness, and his past mistakes make him a character who feels real. Scott, while also flawed, often comes off as too perfect or idealistic, making him less relatable and harder for some readers and viewers to connect with.

7. Dynamic Relationships: Logan’s relationships, especially his complicated dynamics with other X-Men like Jean Grey, Rogue, and Professor X, add layers to his character. His rivalry with Scott over Jean Grey is a prime example of the tension and emotional depth that Logan brings to the story, often overshadowing Scott’s more straightforward approach.

8. Physicality and Presence: Logan’s physicality and combat style—feral, visceral, and hands-on—make him stand out in action scenes. His berserker rage and healing factor make him a force to be reckoned with, providing a stark contrast to Scott’s more controlled, strategic use of his powers.

9. Cultural Impact: Logan’s character has transcended the comics, becoming an iconic figure in pop culture largely thanks to Hugh Jackman’s portrayal in the X-Men films. His gruff voice, memorable one-liners, and lone-wolf attitude have cemented him as a fan-favorite, whereas Scott has struggled to achieve the same level of impact.

10. Moral Ambiguity: Logan’s constant moral struggle—choosing between his violent nature and his desire to protect—adds a level of ambiguity and intrigue. This inner conflict allows for deeper storytelling, as opposed to Scott, who often embodies the "boy scout" leader trope, which can be seen as less nuanced.

Overall, Logan’s combination of complexity, raw emotion, relatability, and anti-hero appeal make him a more compelling character to many fans compared to Scott Summers’ more straightforward and traditional heroic role.