So we were gooning for a few hours like normal at his place. After a long session he always complains about how his fleshlight isn't good enough. He usually asks me to give him head, but I always tell him no because I'm straight. Tonight he says he "needs the real thing" and asks if he can use my ass. I keep telling him no, but he keeps begging and telling me "just the tip" and stuff. I'm about ready to finish, so I say he can do it if I can do it to him though. But just to help us finish off, he has to pull out. I don't want him to fuck me, just get a few pumps in to help him finish.

Long story short, just the tip turned into balls deep, and just a few pumps turned into him cumming inside my ass "on accident". I was pretty annoyed because that isn't what we agreed. I didn't want to do any gay stuff. But I figure I'll at least get my turn. But then he says he changed his mind, and he's ready to be done, and he'll let me do it to him next time.

Obviously I don't think I'm going to JO with him anymore, but just curious what other gooners think. Was it gay to let him cum inside me, just because I thought I was going to get to do it too? We didn't touch balls and he legitimately said "sorry bro, no homo" after he pulled out, which I have to admit was funny as shit.