This post has been de-listed
It is no longer included in search results and normal feeds (front page, hot posts, subreddit posts, etc). It remains visible only via the author's post history.
Two posts in one day? What is this sorcery?
This sorcery is the fact that I am totally going to miss a day or two later in the week when I have work.
I tried writing these as I watched the episode so I would forget less details. Tell me if it helped.
Rules of Engagement: I honestly found the intro disturbing. Jadziaâs demeanor on stand doesnât make sense to me. She IS an expert in Klingon Martial Arts. The way I know her, she should have sat there confidently and said, âYes, he give that final order on the holosuite because heâs an expert officer dedicated to executing the program correctly. In Star Fleet exercises, he executes his Star Fleet training perfectly.â Ah, Chief OâBrien, caving under pressure. Sisko in Worfâs quarters is one of the few moments of his that I like. Especially âYouâll wish you had gone into Botany.â That said, I think Sisko is wrong(ish) on two fronts. First, I think it was actually SISKOâS mistake that Worf took command of that ship. Itâs not Worfâs mistake for taking it- Worf has chosen Star Fleet and his Star Fleet training at every fork in the road. He had no reason to doubt himself this time. He wasnât not ready. And second, I donât actually think Worf was wrong for firing on that ship. He wasnât just doing that for him and his ship as Sisko implied. He had a ship full of plague medicine to protect, and war ships were unlcoking, firing, and cloking again. He had, in my opinion, every reason to fire on that ship. But I still loved Siskoâs conviction. He felt believable.
Hard Time: oh man weâre only a few minutes in and this feels brutal. How is Julian simultaneously the most sensitive and insensitive person I can possibly imagine? From, âDonât worry. We took into account all these little details for you,â to âOh yeah, that must have sucked.â That alien in there with him is terrifying. I like that Julianâs identity was first doctor, then friend. Itâs an interesting reminder of both who Julian is as an individual, but also that he was trying to be what Mileâs needed at the time, first and foremost. Julian is still a doctor without Miles. But he is not a friend. Guys Iâm going to be totally honest with you. I think this is an amazing episode, but I wish I hadnât seen it. It was in this case unfortunately very well done in my opinion. I donât actually know what else to say. I could praise Sisko again, I liked his decisiveness. But my heart sort of sunk when he saw the weapons locker and hasnât unsunk. It just feels kind of brutal. Iâm not sure if Iâm going to see the show the same way after this.
Subreddit
Post Details
- Posted
- 4 years ago
- Reddit URL
- View post on reddit.com
- External URL
- reddit.com/r/startrek/co...