Its about to get heated in here These two go down as the most memorable and favorited installments in the series, and personally while I love every single SH game (Downpour included) me and my friend growing up would get into some pretty heated arguements over which was better. I vote 4 because A. The amazing character design behind Walter. B. I absolutely love the feeling of being helpless and trapped, even in other titles you had more freewill. And C. I feel like really EVERY area and character in 4 in memorable, whereas I couldnt remember every level of 2 if I had to tell ya

Well there you go, I love 4, and 2, and all of em, but mostly 4 What say you?