I am kind of following up on my last story. I still have not told my boyfriend about what happened and I dont think I will, I still havent talked to 2 since what happened.

To start this off, I was drunk, and very bored, so I decided to download tinder as Ive never had it before. It only took me about a few minutes until I started getting matches, most of them didnt really catch my eye except this one guy, he was pretty tall, toned, and lightskin, so I waited for him to hit me up, and then we started talking, he asked if I can come over that night but I said no, I was in no right mind to go anywhere that night.

The next day we were just talking, and he asked to meet up and chill so I got an uber and went to his place. Once I got to his place I was really impressed by it, a really nice view, a nice kitchen, a really big bedroom with a walk in shower. At first we just sat on the couch while we were watching some youtube, and I was bored so I started looking through my camera roll, when I was scrolling through I saw a photo of me and my boyfriend at a football game, he told me that was him in the photo, because he was wearing his number, I was like “can I get your autograph?” and he was like yeah bring me the jersey. I went to my boyfriends place to pick up the jersey and then I came back to his apartment wearing the jersey, we sat back down on the couch, and I took off my shirt,which was the jersey, forgetting I only wore a bra, and he autographed it, I gave him a hug and kiss and told him that my boyfriend was gonna love it, then asked him for a shirt to wear so the jersey can dry off.

He came back with another shirt and he said “so you got a boyfriend?” and I said “yeah why?” and he said “nothing, nothing” while giving me a mischievous look, we started talking about our personal lives and then we started getting closer on the couch, eventually he leaned in for a kiss and I kissed him back, I got on top of him and we started making out, after a while we both were completely topless, and he picked me up and took me to the bedroom, where the jersey was sitting and he asked me to put it on, then I got down on my knees and started giving him head while he was on the edge of the bed, once he started groaning he slapped me and threw me on my stomach onto the bed, and thats where he put it in, I let out a really loud moan. He started pulling on my hair when he whispered to me to call him daddy, to which I did, then he pushed me off, layed down, and told me to get on top, to which I got on top of him and started riding him slowly, I said “do you like that daddy?”, to which he said “i love you”, eventually he rolled over and got on top and pulled both my legs up and put them together, he fucked me until he let out a groan and said “Im gonna cum”, then came in me, pulled it out and still came all over me, including the jersey. He told me to go to the bathroom to wash up after and meet me there.

Once he got to the bathroom he turned on the bathtub, and told me he is still sore from his bowl game, so he wanted a massage, I got in the bathtub with him and started rubbing his body and then eventually it led to us having sex again, it almost felt like I was getting waterboarded but it was some of the best sex in my life, after that we went to sleep where we cuddled.

Im not sure what to do, do I leave my boyfriend for him? or do I see both of them at the same time, or do I just tell my boyfriend and get it over with?