This is a story I made up and everyone in it is 18 years old or older.

I showed up to the Halloween party about an hour after it started. There was a ton of people there from my college, mostly hot girls and their jock boyfriends. I hadn’t been invited and almost didn’t go, but this turned into a night I’ll never forget.

I heard about the party through the grape vine. One of the frat houses was throwing it. There was supposed to be free booze and food, and as a broke college kid, how could I pass that up. The only problem was I didn’t know anyone who was going, and I hadn’t been invited.

I decided the best way to get in was to have a costume that fully covered me. I went to the dollar store and checked out their Halloween department. Most of the costumes has been picked over. Almost all of them were cheap and wouldn’t hide who I really was. Then I seen the scream costume.

Perfect! The mask covers my face and head, and the black cloth covers the rest of my body. I even grabbed a fake bloody knife to complete the look. I went and paid and got an Uber to the party.

When I got there, the party was in full swing. Everyone was in their costumes, and they looked amazing. Most of the guys had on scary or super hero costumes, and most of the girls had on some kind of sluty costume. Sluty nurse, sluty vampire, even a sluty picachu.

As I walked in the door a couple of the guys looked at me and yelled, “Hey, Billy’s back.” Billy was the head of the frat house, and responsible for paying for all the beer and food. I turned around and looked behind me but I didn’t see Billy anywhere. Then I realized, they thought I was Billy.

They walked up to me one of them said, “We can’t thank you enough for this party.” Another one interrupted him and said, “but we’re gonna try. Come this way.” And they began leading me upstairs.

I was a little concerned. I wasn’t Billy. I wasn’t even supposed to be here. All I could do was go where they led me. I was panicking a little bit as we walked up the stairs. All I knew is I couldn’t say a word or my voice would expose me.

We got to the top of the stairs and they opened a bedroom door and said “Enjoy”. I walked into the bedroom two find a sexy, mostly naked, nun and a cat feeling each other up and looking at me. “These two girls would like to show you their appreciation, also they are pledging to the sorority next door and would like to use you as a reference.” One of the guys told me. They then pushed me in and shut the door.

The two girls were sexy as fuck. They had to be the two hottest pledges. The nun said “ My names Jesse.” She was a 6’ tall brunette, with long tone legs and a perfect rack. She had a very tone body and obviously worked out regularly. The cat said “My names Catherine” Catherine was 5’7”, blonde hair, smaller tits, but her black bra was pushing them up just right, and her ass was out of this world. She wasn’t quite as tone, but her body was still in great shape. The sight of the two of them made my dick begin to grow.

They walked over and started rubbing all over me and grabbing my dick. “What would you like us to do first?” they said together with sexy voices and longing looks.

I couldn’t speak, I just looked back an forth between them as they felt and kissed my body through my costume. Then Jesse said “I know what he wants.” And got down on her knees and climbed under the black draping costume. I felt her grab my shorts and yank them down, freeing my dick which had ran out of room in my shorts. Then I felt one hand on my dick, another cupped my balls, and then the warm wet feeling of a mouth sliding down my shaft.

This girl was a pro. Her lips were tightly squeezing my shaft and her tongue was sliding back and forth as she moved up and down my full length, moaning the whole time.

A slight moan escaped my lips. Catherine was watching her head moving back and forth under the costume while rubbing my chest with one hand and the other hand on my back. She looked up at me and reached up to pull off my mask. I stopped her hand just before it reached it and shook my head no. “Oh, we’re gonna leave it on I see. Well, I better help my friend. I can’t let her do all the hard work.” She said licking her lips.

She dropped down and climbed under the costume with Jesse. Then I felt one mouth come off of me and another replace it. She wasn’t quite as skilled as Jesse. She couldn’t fit me fully in her mouth, and she didn’t work her tongue, but she was definitely giving it all she had.

I remember thinking, how on earth did I get so lucky. They continued to work my shaft, taking turns, sometimes making out at the tip, and sometimes running their mouths down the sides together. It was heaven.

Continued in part 2:

https://www.reddit.com/r/sexstories/s/JK7Sf0rq8w