This is a story from when I was in college. There was this girl that I had a lot of classes with, Casi. She was light skinned, long blond hair, black eyebrows, freckles, and glasses. She was a good Christian girl, like I mean a 'wear a cross around her neck and say a prayer before bed' girl.

Casi and I would text during class. We both had MacBooks and some of our classes had us all sit in a circle so we could just text all class and the professor would assume we were typing notes. She and I didn't have extensive conversations, but I kept texting her because she was always hinting that she wanted me to ask her out. I thought it was cool that she was being pretty forward about it, so I figured why not take her on a date?

We got dinner together one night and afterward I suggested going back to my place. She seemed cool with it, and it wasn't very late so I figured I might as well shoot my shot. We got back and were watching a movie when I went in for it. We made out for a while and pretty soon I was grabbing at her tits. They were small and perky, just enough to hold onto with one hand. I started reaching down her pants but she stopped me. She pulled back and started telling me about how the Bible says we have to wait until marriage. I told her that was okay, we didn't have to do anything else. I ended up leaving shortly after that.

A few days later sitting in class she texted me. Casi said she was sorry about how things went down, and she had an idea if I wanted to meet up again. She started telling me about how the Bible just says that a person can't "spill their seed outside the body" and says nothing about other possibilities. I looked up from my computer over at her. I thought to myself, "is she talking about the poophole loophole? Does anyone believe that?" But I made a serious face as I texted back, "my place? Like around 10?" I needed some time after class to go buy some lube.

Casi arrived early and was wearing a sweater and a skirt. We hung out in the kitchen of my apartment and drank a few glasses of wine--Casi was conservative, but she would still drink wine. It wasn't long before I had her bent over my kitchen table. She had bright white cotton underwear. I pulled up her skirt and started to play with her asshole over her panties. "You ever do this before?" I asked. She said "no, I've given a lot of blowjobs." I laughed, but she was serious. She told me she thought she was there to blow me, not anal. I told her to get down on her knees then first. She was used to being on her knees I guess (probably from weekly prayer), because she didn't complain about me fucking her face for quite a while. She had a really cute face and she liked getting slapped with my cock. After a while, she told me she was ready to try it. I bent her back over again and pulled down her soft panties. Her asshole was small and pink, and I started licking it. Her pussy was hairy but tasted delicious, and apparently there were no religious issues with tongue fucking her, I just couldn't stick my dick in her pussy. I then lubed up my cock and her ass and jammed it inside. Her ass was so tight I came within a few minutes.

Casi insisted that since we were "dating" I needed to walk with her to our class. I told her if she wants that, then she needs to do something for me first. So everyday before class I was emptying a load of cum in her ass. Casi would wear outfits to class that looked like she was a Catholic schoolgirl, and I loved pulling up her little skirts and pulling down her panties. Sometimes I hid her panties after we were done so she had to go to class without any underwear on. I sat close to her in class and could often smell my own cum leaking out of her. She would make these little fart/squirt noises sometimes and people would look at her. She would get mad when I kept her panties because at least her panties kept in the distinct smell of cum and ass that only an anal creampie could produce--leading boys sitting around her to smirk when she sat down. I would give her the panties back only if she sucked me off and cleaned my cock after cumming deep in her ass. I told her if she ever wanted a different taste, she could stick her tongue in my ass ten times and I'd give her panties back. She would sometimes take that option and would let me sit on her face.

No matter how many times I fucked Casi in the ass, she would still moan as I put it in her. Sometimes she wouldn't stop talking while we fucked. She would keep repeating certain phrases, like "oh my goodness," or "oh my word." I tried hooking my fingers in her mouth while I fucked her from behind. I also tried grabbing her arms and forcing her face into her pillow. Her arms were covered in freckles. But if those methods didn't work, I would usually pull my cock out of her ass and shove it down her throat. I liked slapping my balls off her chin when I would cum deep in her throat.

One time she had a meeting for the Young Republicans right before class, so she could not come over to my room beforehand. So when she got to class that day, she smelled a familiar smell--only this time it was coming from Katheryn, my long-time friend with benefits, who was spreading her legs slightly enough to let it pour out of her and onto the inside of her dress. Casi accused me of cheating, and I denied it, but obviously between you and me, I pounded the fuck out of that ass. I told her if she wanted, she could go lick Katheryn's ass, since it is still in there and compare the taste. She told me that would be a sin and dropped the subject.

One day she asked if she could jerk me off rather than use her asshole. She said there were plenty of places to cum besides her asshole. Her throat, for example. I told her only her face would work, because the Bible says if he loves her he will cover her face. She told me that line was about prostitutes, and meant something different, but I told her we had different interpretations. And pretty soon, I was splattering her glasses. During the remaining few weeks of the semester, I came on her face a couple dozen times. Casi gave me a key to her apartment and I used it a lot. Sometimes if I was just bored or I needed to relieve stress, she told me she didn't mind as long as she could keep studying or whatever it was she was doing while I jerk off. I liked pulling her panties down, and sniff them while I stare at her, fully naked and stroking myself. She would just lay on the couch, reading her textbook, ass fully exposed. When she went home for Thanksgiving break I didn't jerk off the whole time. I edged myself in her bed for two hours before she got back, filling my balls to explode on her face. She had cute freckles on her forehead and I usually aimed for that. That time, I shot 8 or 9 ropes that went from her chin to her forehead, a couple of them straight across her eyes.

I preferred going to her place because she had two hot roommates. Sometimes when I was fucking Casi in the ass especially hard, the bed would slam against the wall and the door would pop open slightly. I would catch one of her roommates walk past, then linger in the doorway. I also liked her apartment because from my vantage point on the sofa in the living room, I could always see down the hall, where the bedrooms and bathroom was located. Casi and I would sit there on the couch, watching a movie, and one of her roommates would walk down the hall after a shower, toweling themselves off as they walked, showing off their asses. Sometimes they would go and lay naked in their bedrooms with the door open, and a time or two I caught them each fingering themselves. I even caught one of them giving a blowjob to a big black dildo and filming herself on her phone doing it. You should know, these girls were both very attractive, but they were also geeks and introverted. They were both horny but afraid of losing their virginity. They often would text with guys from class and send photos/videos, but always back out before meeting to hook up. A couple dozen guys on campus (myself included) had videos of these two masturbating on their phone. One video even has one of them putting the black dildo up against the door and fucking it doggystyle. Its almost an hour long and ends with her squirting all over the floor. I heard it happen live. I was down the hall jerking off on Casi's face. She sent me the video of her fucking the dildo when it was over and I opened it while I kept jerking off. Casi was hunched over her computer at her desk finishing a term paper and wasn't providing much jerk off material, so I sat on the other side of her desk and jerked off to her roommate's video.

Of course, you know me by now, I ultimately fucked the roommates, including both at the same time. Once they saw the size of my cock and my moves pounding Casi's ass, it was all over. One was a brunette with big tits but she dressed to conceal them. She had brown eyes and wore big glasses and studied at the library a lot. I would usually titfuck her. The other was a blonde with a fairly plain face. The face did not matter much though because she had this big square ass--you know how the bottom of the cheeks are flat? They dressed up as Daphne and Velma for Halloween, and when neither one went home with a guy, I kept them company--fucking Velma's cute face and Daphne's fat ass. Neither would let me use their pussy, but the ass was fair game, and when they were together, I would swap between their asses and mouths, making each taste the other.

Casi ultimately caught me cheating. She got very upset and yelled at me, but I was determined to cum first, so I tuned out the first couple of minutes. She told me we weren't dating, which was fine by me, since we only had a few months left of school. I kept fucking her roommates, and I made sure to walk to the bathroom naked after fucking one of them, leaving the door wide open so she could see the cum pour out of her roommate's ass. Casi believed that her ass was like her virginity, and she needed to marry the one person who she let use it. This meant that she let me hit it a few times again the rest of year, but at least those times I didn't have to walk her to class afterward, because we would usually "break up" after I blew my load.

My only regret is never getting the three of them together...