I remember the conversation clearly. 

“You did the same thing for Alexis, why can’t I help Ben out before he leaves for college?” my wife Julie quipped back. 

Several years after I took the virginity of our babysitter Alexis, my wife had asked if she could do the same for our tutor Ben. I was completely caught off guard by her request. I didn’t know what to say. Yes, I had slept with Alexis, but that was nearly 10 years ago. Julie and I had never talked about sleeping with other people and now all of a sudden she had asked to sleep with our tutor?

In the years since my last story, things have changed between Julie and I. Julie now works from home, while I accepted a promotion that had me go back into the office, and requires me to travel about once a month. 

Our daughter had recently been struggling in science, so we hired a tutor to come by after school and teach her. We looked around at a bunch of those professional services, but they were all really expensive. Once again, we relied on a recommendation from our neighbors. 

We were at a party hosted by our local homeowners association when my wife started talking to a neighbor that lived a few doors down. She taught AP Physics to seniors at the nearby high school. When she heard that our daughter was struggling in science, she recommended one of her students as a private tutor. His name was Ben. 

Ben was 18 and the neighbor said he was one of the best students she’d ever had. He was polite, respected the other students in class, and seemed to know everything about math and science. He was going to a prestigious university on the west coast, but his family wasn’t very well off, so he was looking to make some cash on the side. 

To Julie and I it was a no brainer. So we invited Ben to our house for a trial session, and it was exactly what our daughter needed. We had Ben come Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday each week. He’d arrive around 3pm, shortly after our daughter returned from school. He’d help her with her math and science homework and usually left by 6pm, right around the time I got home. 

Occasionally our paths would cross. We’d exchange pleasantries, I’d ask how things were going, but that was about it. He seemed like a nice young man, and most importantly our daughter’s grades in math and science were really improving. 

Ben turned 19 in May, just before the school year ended. It was becoming more and more real that our time with Ben was starting to come to a close. We knew he’d be leaving for school in August and next year we’d probably have to find a new tutor. 

We decided to make the most of our time with Ben and invited him to come during the summer and continue tutoring our daughter. This way she could get a jump start on the next year’s math and science lessons. He agreed. 

Each day during the summer we would arrive in the morning around 9am. He’d spend a couple hours tutoring our daughter and leave around 11am. This meant I never saw Ben. I’d occasionally get updates from Julie. Sometimes the three of them would get lunch or see a movie. It seemed like they had all grown really close. 

In late July I left on a business trip for a week. It was routine. I left Monday morning, worked until Thursday evening, then returned home Friday. When I arrived home Julie greeted me with the usual hug and kiss. She caught me up on the week’s events, and then eventually she and I retired to the bedroom. 

I was taking a long hot shower, washing off that grimey feeling you get from being in taxis and airports and planes most of the day. I frequently daydreamed in the shower, especially when I was horny and my mind started to wonder about Alexis. I’d imagine us fucking right here on the shower floor. How I came inside her. I wondered how she was doing. Did she think about having sex with me still?

I was just about to turn off the water when Julie joined me. It was a nice surprise, especially considering we hadn’t had sex in a week. I admired her long blonde hair and her C cup breasts. I loved how her hips flared out from her stomach and how her ass had managed to remain firm and round all these years. She was still hot even after all these years of marriage. 

“So there’s one thing I didn’t tell you about.” she said. 

“Okay?” I asked, realizing that this meant there was going to have strings attached to it. 

“It’s about Ben.” she said. 

“Okay, this is an odd place to discuss our daughter’s tutor.” I joked. 

“Well yesterday she left at lunch to go see a movie with a friend, so I took Ben out to lunch.” Julie explained. 

“Okay.” I shrugged. 

“Well we got to talking about him going away to college in a few weeks. I asked him if he was nervous about anything.” she explained, slowly getting to her point.

“Okay. What’s the big deal?” I asked. 

“Well he said he was most nervous about girls and that he’d never had a girlfriend. He’d never even kissed a girl.” Julie had started to ramble now. 

Was Julie going to suggest setting Ben up with our daughter?

“So then I thought about that thing you did for Alexis.” Julie said, catching my attention. 

“Alexis?” I said, pretending I had forgotten who she was.

“Yeah, remember our old babysitter? Remember how you took her virginity and taught her about guys?” 

“Oh, right. Of course I remember Alexis.” I said, wishing Julie would get to the point quickly. 

“Well… What if I did the same for Ben?” she asked. 

It was like a gut punch listening to my wife ask to sleep with another person. 

“I… What? No. Come on.” I said, spewing words out of my mouth as I thought about what to say.

“You did the same thing for Alexis, why can’t I help Ben out before he leaves for college?” my wife Julie quipped back. 

“But…” I said and then trailed off.

“I’ve never asked to sleep with anyone else. I think it’s only fair that you let me even the score with Ben.” she explained.

She had a point. I did get to take Alexis’ virginity. Shoot, I’d even continued to sleep with her behind my wife’s back for a while. This entire time, over 10 years, she’d never asked to sleep with someone else. She never hung it over my head, until right now. 

“I… I…” 

Images raced through my mind of Julie having sex with Ben. He’d be her first new person in nearly 15 years. 

Are you going to be okay with this? I asked myself. 

Do you really have a choice? I thought. 

“I guess.” I sighed. 

Julie’s face lit up. She wrapped her arms around my neck and gave me a deep passionate kiss. 

“So what’s your plan?” I asked. 

“Well… I was thinking about next weekend. You have that hunting trip with your brothers and our daughter will be staying the weekend at the Jennings’ house to celebrate Chrissy’s birthday.” Julie explained.

“A whole weekend?!” I exclaimed, remembering that Alexis and I only got a day. 

“It’s different with guys, you know how it is. It takes longer to recover and I want to make sure I can teach him a bunch of stuff.” she explained. 

I had been looking forward to this hunting trip with my brothers. We took it every year, a chance to get away from work, our wives, our kids, and bond over beer and the outdoors. 

“I… That sounds like a good plan.” I said. 

“Same rules apply though. You have to send me updates, let me know what’s going on.” I explained. 

“Sure!” Julie said. 

Out of nowhere I blurted out, “I’d like pictures too.” 

I wasn’t sure if that’s what I really wanted. Did I want to see Ben fucking my wife? It's too late now.

“Uh… Okay, I can ask him if he’s okay with that.” she explained. 

“Anything else?” she asked.

I paused for a moment, trying to think of other rules.

“I… Uh… I… Don’t think so?” I said. 

“Protection?” Julie asked.

“Oh!” I exclaimed.

How could I forget that part?

“I… Sure, use condoms.” I said. 

“So now cumming inside me?” she asked, biting her lower lip. 

I imagined Ben cumming inside my wife. Filling her pussy with his fertile seed. 

“I uh… I think I would prefer condoms.” I said. 

Truth is, I wasn’t sure how I felt about protection. I figured Julie required I use them with Alexis, it was only fair I did the same to her. Deep down, I wondered what it would be like to fuck Julie after Ben had cum inside her. 

“So we have a deal?” Julie asked. 

I hesitated again, “We have a deal.”