It seems like it gets harder and harder to shop for my 5 nieces each year. For ease, I prefer to get them all the same thing (or different variations of the same thing) and since they all have so much, I lean toward small gifts, non-toys, and/or consumables. (I’m flexible though, like I could get the older ones one thing and the younger ones another)

Some examples are: a few years ago I got them all super hero capes with their initials on them and they were a hit. And this year my sister is getting them all name necklaces. (The gifts do not need to be personalized. These examples just happen to be, lol). Last year I decided to just get gifts for each of the whole families but I don’t think it went over as well. (I am open to doing that again though if someone has a brilliant idea).

Because I know someone will say experiences or memberships, I think they have enough memberships. I only live near one of them so that also makes experience gifts a bit harder.

For reference, they are split across 3 families: a 9 year old and an almost 6 year old in one family, a 4 and 6 year old in the second family, and a 5 year old who is an only child. They all live in a warm climate (California)

Thank you for any ideas!