This post has been de-listed
It is no longer included in search results and normal feeds (front page, hot posts, subreddit posts, etc). It remains visible only via the author's post history.
I was a lower middle class kid with a regional accent arriving at Oxford uni in 2006. By pure accident I had applied to one of the poshest colleges and all of the tropes in the film were absolutely on point. I wore the wrong things, my tutors looked down on me, I was counting out pound coins while my friends were swiping daddy's credit card. People were cruel and said nasty, snobbish things behind my back and to my face.
However, while I started watching the film thinking it would be cathartic, I ended it feeling like I'd been slapped in the face. I spent a lot of time around the upper classes at uni and they view the middle class as unsophisticated, boring and jealous. That might not sound so bad but in the eyes of the aristocracy those are about the worst things you can possibly be. From the sad spag bol to the unattractive new build to the sinister Oliver it all just screamed "yes us poshos are silly and entitled and a bit mean...but at least we're not you".
The portrayal of the northern maths nerd shows exactly whose side Fennel is on here. If Fennel and I had ever met at Oxford she probably would have thought I was an uncultured bore with a rough accent and crap clothes. I genuinely feel so cheated that my experience of being the outsider at Oxford has been told by one of the insiders.
(This is probably the wrong place to write this as I'm sure everyone is a super fan but I just felt the need to vent!)
[Edit: Given a lot of people have seen this post I just want to say I really hope this doesn't put off any state school kids from applying to Oxford. There are colleges which are majority state school and far more inclusive. Don't let this amazing institution be the sole preserve of the rich and privately educated. You can help to change it!]
Hahaha you donāt have to apologise - I lived in Ox for 12 years, got off the rollercoaster of wanting approval somewhere around year 2
Definitely. Fitting in feels high stakes when home is on the other side of the planet.
Noticed my comment before was downvoted, not sure which egos were more likely to be trampled, Americans like myself or some class sensitive Brit. Maybe E. Fennelās herself.
Gosh I totally appreciate this. I was an American at Ox and felt like I was able to confuse enough class things to get away with a lot. I also was there more recently and itās changed a lot. But I felt the ironies really keenly watching this film, Americans tend to associate ourselves as viewers with the wealthy, upstairs protagonists and I think many of my peers did that with Fennels film, not realizing they are definitely the āgraspingā sort sheās looking straight at. It truly was horrifying to me.
Subreddit
Post Details
- Posted
- 8 months ago
- Reddit URL
- View post on reddit.com
- External URL
- reddit.com/r/saltburn/co...
Ya most donāt understand the class system of the UK and the giant leap culturally between upper middles and the upper class. Itās a world difference. And itās not necessarily about money. Although in Saltburn thatās a necessary component to Felix and Oliās dynamic.