So a month ago I bought a black label disc of silent hill 1 on ebay for 60$ including shipping and tax.

Games scratched but works perfectly fine, beat the game with no hiccups, not to jinx it

Anyways few days later I found a guy selling the greatest hits case and manual for 40$, a really cheap price. I originally bought the game to play it and didn't care about having it complete but I knew this was a good opportunity so I bought it too.

From a collectors point of view its nice to have the entire thing but does mix and matching case and game hurt the value of it??? I don't plan on reselling the game for a ridiculous price anytime soon, just kind of curious