Long story short: I recently launched a second podcast. I don't want to create a separate patreon for it because I expect there will be a lot of audience overlap and people won't want to pay twice. I still want to provide benefits for both shows (ad free, bonus episodes, etc.) in separate rss feeds.

There are plenty of hosts that offer a free-to-join, members-only feed, but on further inspection, they're all aimed at corporate use and priced to match. Affordable private feeds all seem to cap subscribers at 50-100 people.

Is there any option out there that's both members-only and not absurdly expensive? Or better yet, a way to do it directly on Patreon? I'd love to even find something that's capped at 300-500 people and deal with exceeding that later.

On r/podcasting yesterday, the best suggestion I've seen so far is maybe Supercast, but even they seem to reserve multiple feeds for a higher bracket, and their base price would effectively require eliminating my $1 tier, which I'm not a huge fan of.