It's difficult to even find a title for this post. I (m46) started into the world of enm/poly last year. I am happily married and after many discussions with my wife, I started dating someone (f36). She and I fell in love and it was amazing. She and my wife were friends. We had an incredible connection and I was more happy and fulfilled than I ever had been in my life. Cut to, after over a year of dating I found out that my girlfriend had sex with a friend of hers and never told me. I initially found out because her friend told a mutual friend of ours. After many conversations my girlfriend finally spilled the beans. I am devastated. It happened more than a month before I found out. She said she never told me because it happened very fast and was afraid I would leave her. She and I have had numerous conversations about dating others and I always supported her seeing anyone she wanted. All I asked for was communication. That's why all of this is such a shock. I am so sad and very disillusioned with poly/ enm now. She has said many times that she knows that she broke the golden rule of this lifestyle by not disclosing this. I miss her so much and I don't think I can trust her moving forward. I don't know if I am looking for advice? Insight? I am just so sad. I have tried to ask what I could have done to make telling me easier for her. She has stated several times that I did nothing wrong. Simply that she made a huge mistake. Any thoughts are welcome.
Since you've gotten two people questioning your basic rules instead of addressing your question....
I feel the need to say this, it's perfectly normal, reasonable and common for ENM partners to want to know about other partners.
Not only for sexual health risk awareness, but also just as a policy for awareness of what is going on in your partners life.
That's 100% valid.
Violations of agreements is cheating in ENM. I can't say why she didn't tell you and won't presume to know her mind, but it's a violation of your agreement regardless and thus, cheating.
Lying (and lying by omission) is arguably the most harmful thing you can do in any relationship, because it destroys trust.
Her reaction means she knew better and did it anyway.
I'm so sorry OP, please know that your rules and feelings are valid.
Yeah, this is what it always comes back to for me.
And I disagree with rule-breaking being responded to by reconsideration of the rule. That feels like you're rewarding the person who broke the rule by saying "but it's okay" when it isn't.
If a rule is hard to follow, the answer is a conversation about the rule, not breaking it.
Subreddit
Post Details
- Posted
- 7 months ago
- Reddit URL
- View post on reddit.com
- External URL
- reddit.com/r/nonmonogamy...
It's absolutely valid to have an agreement that requires prior or contemporaneous communication.
If for no other reason than awareness of sexual health risk, it's valid to expect to know about other sexual partners.
They both agreed to this rule, so I'm not sure why you keep pushing your own opinion about that rule here.