Request Thread

Trial Thread

C4mmo confessed to two counts of grief and to the 600 charge. Therefore, the only parts of the prosecution that matter beyond this are whether they did or did not present clear evidence that THREE or more victims exist (were actually griefed) and gave permission to sue. Otherwise, the confession is already sufficient for 2 counts. I reminded the prosecution of this before they began their arguments.

Did they meet this bar? Let’s consider first the hard evidence. How many victims does it clearly show? Well, screenshots were only given for three blocks of obsidian. I checked all of them in game, and they correspond to the first floors only of the Koshermart, the synagogue, and the starbucks, respectively.

According to the prosecution, those three spaces are owned by only 2 people: Figasaur and Cr0c. Whether or not the JQPA owns one of them or whether or not the JQPA even exists is irrelevant, because if it does exist, Figasaur still owns a majority controlling share according to himself, and if it doesn’t exist, then it’s also his, just his normal build. Either way, it’s his, and he’s fully accountable for it, responsible for it, and is the victim. So the JQPA does not matter here. The same outcome results regardless.

Which brings us to the only remaining evidence in considering if there is a third or fourth victim: the witness testimonies.

• KalinkaKochana: This witness did not even claim that they were obby bombed at their residence, let alone add any new hard evidence OR eyewitness testimony that they observed C4mmo doing anything. So no evidence was provided here, and the testimony was therefore not helpful. Moving on…

• Cr0c: This witness also mentioned no new evidence (material evidence nor eyewitnessing) regarding c4mmo obby bombing any of the charged properties. He does say his apartment was blocked, but offered no snitch evidence nor claimed to have witnessed c4mmo doing it. So his testimony does nothing to incriminate c4mmo in this apartment blocking (Also "blocking" does not even make it clear that the property itself was griefed, versus an approach to the property such as a road). He also briefly mentions roads, but since the prosecution does not have road owners’ permission to sue, this is not relevant to the trial (also he doesn’t provide evidence of the road grief being c4mmo either, anyway).

• SouthernBloc: Again, offers no evidence, whether material evidence or eyewitnessing, of c4mmo obby bombing anything, and is therefore also not helpful.

So despite several witness testimonies, there is zero additional evidence (whether snitches or eyewitnessing or anything else) of any obby bombing done by c4mmo to additional victims beyond figasaur and cr0c.

Thus, I find c4mm0 guilty of 2 charges of griefing 100.03, for the only two victims that were proven to be bombed by c4mmo. I also agree with the prosecution that the use of reinforced obby (confessed) raises the charges via 100.04 one degree higher, making them into two counts of 100.02 instead. The max sentence for 2 charges of 100.02 is two weeks pearling.

I also find c4mm0 guilty of the 600.01 charge, by merit of confession. However, by law, a 600.01 charge that is covered by any other statute carries no charges nor reparations.

The total sentence is therefore 2 weeks.

Reparations are to be agreed upon by the parties. You must attempt either agreement between yourselves, or arbitration first, and if that fails to be unanimous, come back and ask me and I will assign reparations. Be aware that no reparations are allowed to be considered, by law, for the 600 charge, only for the 100 charges.

As in recent other trials involving obby bombing, the sentence is to be carried out by exile pearl, unless anyone is willing to donate additional mana needed to elevate the punishment to prison pearl, in which case it may be spent to serve any remaining time as prison pearl. This is due to the heinous and serious nature of obby bombing (also the reason for max sentences above).

Thank you.