My Fiancé [25f] and I [32m] just had our first threesome with a guy [27m] we met on Reddit. This has been in the works for a long time, and finally consummating it is a huge satisfaction.

This has been a fantasy of mine for quite some time. It probably stems from some porn I saw as a teen, but no one wants to hear my Freudian analysis. My Fiancé, let’s call her Sammy, and I have been together for three years and have no secrets between us. I first introduced her to my fantasy pretty early on into the relationship. She is a total pleaser sexually and admitted to me that she had thought about being spit roasted (although she didn’t know that’s what it was called at the time). We never really acted on the fantasy apart from maybe watching some MFM porn together. She would eventually tell me that she liked the thought but didn’t want anyone else’s dick but mine, who am I to complain. I put my fantasy on the back burner for a long time, and our sex life between the two of us just got better with time.

I’m not sure how I first started exploring Reddit’s NSFW pages, but I know I really enjoyed going to r/hotwife to find new porn. I’m definitely not into the cuckolding culture, but sharing my girl and watching her being fucked is my ultimate fantasy. Luckily I found that I’m not really too alone in that fantasy. So I started diving deeper and eventually found r/foridar4r. I showed Sammy this, and brought up the possibility of opening our relationship up again. To my surprise, she was surprisingly open to it. We decided to create a post there and put some feelers out not really knowing what to expect. We ended up creating this post {link}. Anyone with even the slightest r4r experience can imagine the flood gates of dick picks, douche bags, and wannabe bulls that we were subjected to. Not our thing at all. It was actually quite funny, but there were two guys out of about two hundred that seemed to have potential for us to vibe. Eventually we narrowed that down to one let’s call home Mike.

Mike and I started chatting on Reddit while Sammy was at work, and I eventually gave him her google voice number which I also have accesses to (why she has a google voice account could be an entirely different equally juicy post). They’d chat on there a bit with some basic get to know you questions, and I might chime in here or there. Sammy and I ended up staying at a hotel and had some friends over to hang out with. Mike and Sammy ended up texting each other while our friends were over and for the first time their conversation turned sexual. They were talking about their kinks and all the things they wanted to do together. Sammy has a thing for dominating men, and she loves to have her throat fucked. She told about him about her desire to be used by us both and basically begged for his cock. The whole time we are playing innocent drinking games with our friends and she’s holding conversation with them like nothing is happening. Meanwhile I’m trying to conceal my rock hard erection while trying not to stare at my phone for too long. The next morning I gave Mike our real numbers and start a group chat between us.

I wanted to up the ante a little bit so I snuck a couple of nude photos of her while she was in the shower. Mike went nuts. Sammy laughed when she saw the pictures and gave me a playful eye roll that I’ve become a custom to getting when she’s okay with something but not horny. The day passes and we end up taking a bath in our luxurious jacuzzi. Sammy is feeling sexy and wants to take photos to share to Mike. We take close to a hundred photos and select some of our favorites to send to him. We show him some really sexy nudes of her tits, ass, and feet because I like them. Still no face pictures as we’ve still chosen to stay somewhat anonymous to this point. Mike was ecstatic. You could definitely feel the sexual tension building. We made plans to have him come over for a game night with just the three of us. Sammy, despite all her nudes and sexting, still wasn’t ready to commit to having sex or even hooking up at this point. Mike was completely cool with the idea of a meeting without any pretenses. It’s honestly was a big reason why we choose Mike out of so many other guys because he never pressured anything.

We finally had Mike over one evening after work. He’s an extremely nice guy and easy to get along with. He later confessed he thought he was getting catfished. He was blown away by Sammy. She’s very attractive. Long athletic toned legs, perky bubble butt with a great shape, fit athletic body type, perfect nipples on perky b cup tits, and a naturally gorgeous face with beautiful bright green eyes. She wears her long brunette hair down, doesn’t need make-up and completes the sexy girl next door look with her glasses. That night we just got to know each other a little. We drank had some conversations about sexual history and our preferences that we’d never dare to tell anyone else in our circle. It was really fun and felt a little slutty, but outside of a dare for Mike and Sammy to exchange shirts where he saw she didn’t have a bra on it was pretty PG13. Mike was making good on his promise to not pressure Sammy into anything, and it would pay off for him. We said our goodbyes for the night and sent him on his way. As soon as I locked the door behind him, Sammy jumped all over me like she was in heat. She needed dick after being teased all night and I fucked her brains out on our bed. Sammy told me the next day that she had a lot of fun, and still wasn’t sure if she’d end up sleeping with him or not but wanted to hang out again.

We spent the next two weeks talking a little bit via text. Made a couple of soft plans that had be be rescheduled, but always planned on meeting soon. I got particularly horny one morning and sent Mike a video I had made of bending Sammy over and fucking her from behind. It was the first time he’d seen her pussy or my cock. I told him I was about to fuck her again, and I told him she was fantasizing about his cock in her mouth. He asked if we wanted to meet again and Sammy was ready to make it happen. We finally made plans to have sex, but said nothing was guaranteed. We’d just see how the night went.

Mike came over again on a night both Sammy and I had been working all day. We had just enough time to shower and clean up a bit before Mike was due to come over. We didn’t really talk about what we were willing to do that night or get a feel for each other’s expectations before Mike arrived. When he did arrive Sammy was still in the shower and him and I just made small talk and poured our first drinks. Sammy joins us and I pour her a nice tall whiskey drink to put her at ease. We kind of shoot the shit for a while catching up and sipping our drinks. Sammy and I teach Mike this card game that we like to play with friends and he picks it up pretty quick. I know that Sammy isn’t wearing a bra under her shirt again. So I throw out that the loser has to take their shirt off. I get a dagger of a look from Sammy. She obliged anyway, but she’s easily the best at the game and my gamble backfired. I’m the one sitting there with my shirt off at the end of the hand. It had been about an hour and a half since Mike had gotten there, and Sammy definitely did not seem ready to jump into a threesome. It seemed all hope was lost, but the ace up my sleeve is a truth or dare app I had on my phone. Let me tell you that if you’re trying to do something similar to what I’m describing, do yourself a favor and get something like this on your phone.

After playing some more cards, I suggested to the two of them we play truth or dare. I’d already showed Sammy the app. I’d paid for an extension to make the game very raunchy if wanted. But I told her we’d only play the PG version. After a couple of easy truths, Mike takes the first dare. It dared him to do the next few turns with the lights off. It sounds silly, but we’re now sitting at the table by candle light and the mood has completely changed. I up the game to the R rated version and that’s were we started having fun. Sammy is taking all truths, but Mike and I start taking dares. He’s dared to suck on Sammy’s lip. As he’s reading it he’s a little bashful and suggests that they didn’t have to do it. But Sammy insisted it was okay, and I watched as Mike came over leaned in and makes out with my fiancé in front of me lingering a little to suck her lip as dared. A few rounds of a mix of dares and truths has Sammy topless, Mike in boxers, and me butt ass naked. My losing streak carried on from the cards. Sammy finally takes a dare. She’s dared to sit me in a chair and do whatever it took to get me moaning in under a minute. She bent down on her knees in front of me and spit on my cock to prepare it for a sloppy blowjob. I pulled back her hair so Mike could watch how she sucks cock. She didn’t tease me or anything, but instead went straight to deep throating my shaft. She knew she only had a minute, and she hates to loose. Mike looked on and started stroking his cock through his boxers as Sammy put on a performance. Her head game is wonderfully sloppy, and I can feel her spit dripping on my balls. She had me moaning and satisfied her dare. It was my turn next and I was dared to hug Sammy’s butt for a minute. I’m not really sure how to hug an ass but I knew what I was going to do with my minute. I told Sammy to stand up and put both hands on the the table. I arch her back a bit so her butt is perked up a bit as I kneel behind her. I start grabbing handfuls of her ass checks with both my hands through her tight booty shorts. I pull her shorts around her ankles so I can grab her bare ass. I then peel her panties down she tells me to stop in a laughing way. She didn’t want Mike to know how much she enjoyed being treated like a little slut. I spread her feet apart to reveal her tight little pussy from behind. I looked at Mike and asked him if he wanted to see Sammy get fucked. His reply was obvious, and Sammy reached abound to guide my now throbbing cock inside her as I stood behind her. As I pushed my way slowly deep inside Sammy her hands slid down and she put her head on the table bringing her hips up so I could pull her into me. I loved seeing her hair drape into Mike’s lap. Mike looked on as I started to thrust into Sammy faster. Her pussy was dripping with the thought of putting on a show for our guest. I could tell the only thing she was thinking about was getting fucked, and it didn’t matter from who. I asked her if she was ready to suck Mike’s cock, she said yes as she exhaled. I stood her up as I pulled out of her and she suggested we move from the kitchen table to the bed. I grabbed a candle and we followed her naked ass to bed. My cock was dripping with her wetness, and he was still in his boxers.

Once in our room, I told Mike to get on the side of the bed and loose his boxers. Sammy was already lying on her stomach with her head off the side facing Mike’s rock hard cock. I Jumped on the bed behind Sammy. I watched as Mike was caressing the side of Sammy’s face and then put his hand around the back of her neck as he entered her mouth. Sammy is now sucking on her first new cock in three years. I watch from behind her as her head starts to bob up and down on his dick. I start hearing the unmistakable sound of a dick fucking a throat, and now I’m looking at her glistening pussy right in front of me. Carful not to stop disturb her throating I move Sammy’s knees from a laying position to a kneeling position. Her ass and pussy are up in the air, and can bury my face between her cheeks as I slide my tongue into her lips. Sammy’s clit has perked up from the excitement and I focus on making her cum. I keep glancing up to enjoy the sight of her face being used by Mike’s cock. He’s now being pretty forceful, he pumps a few times and then buries his whole shaft in her throat. It’s a hard face fuck her. She chocked on his cock a few times, but like a good little slut she’d pull him out of her throat to take a few heavy breaths and put him right back in. I couldn’t see her face, but I knew she was probably making quite the little mess. I kept thinking about her telling me about how she wanted to please two cocks at once, and I wanted to fill her tight pussy with Mike shoved down her throat. I got on my knees behind her and spread her ass checks to insert into her. She was dripping with her own juices and my spit. She was still sucking and chocking on Mike as he fucked her throat. This would cause her to tense up for a second and kegle while I was inside her. It almost sent me over the top. I didn’t want to cum yet. I pulled out and tagged Mike in. We switched positions, he started by pinning her down a bit more than I had her. It gave me a good view of his cock initially entering my Fiancé. Sammy’s face had her spit dripping down her chin and smeared on her cheeks from the throating Mike had just laid into her. I couldn’t help but kiss her. I grabbed a fist of hair on the top of her head and tilted her chin up towards me as I kissed this little slut of mine on her used lips. Mike was beginning to find his rhythm. Still pinning her down a bit but she was able to take my cock in her mouth. I was dripping with her juices and she hesitated at first, but as Mike kept going she cared less about tasting herself. He pulled her hips back to get her to a more traditional doggystyle positions. I was able to pull the back of her neck into me and get myself into her throat. Mike was now having his way with her pounding her and smacking her ass. I could feel him thrusting deep inside her through her mouth. Her throat would contract with his deeper thrusts and it would tighten around my cock. I started to hear Mike moan. We were all in a rhythm and Sammy was completely filled with cock. I thought for sure he was on the edge of cumming. The thought of him dropping his load in Sammy sent me over the top. I pulled out of her throat and my cock started to pulsate in her mouth. I caught her off guard and she couldn’t swallow all of my cum. The rest dripped down her chin and on to our bed. Mike didn’t cum. I got to watch him take Sammy, and I let her enjoy his cock without interruption. I saw her “O” face start to form as she told Mike she was cumming. She started to throw it back at him now that she didn’t need to satisfy a cock with her mouth. Mike grabbed her hips and continued to fuck her through her orgasim. He then pulled his cock out and put his shaft in between Sammy’s perk little ass cheeks. I watched his cock throb and shoot his cum all over her back. After lying there a second Sammy sat up. She had a cute little smirk on her face and her hair was in a freshly fucked mess. We all went back to the kitchen everything still lit by candlelight. Mike and I stayed naked, but Sammy put her panties on as we sat and finished our drinks and chatted about what just happened. It was late and Mike and I put our clothes back on. He thanked us for a fun evening and gave Sammy a long hug goodbye. After I locked the door I took Sammy by the hand and led her back to the bed to reclaim her. I stripped her panties off, and went down on her used pussy. I loved the taste of her that was smeared on the outside of her lips. She begged me to fuck her again and I pinned her down as I fucked her from behind. We both came together and I pulled out to cum right where Mike had twenty minutes ago. Exhausted we climbed under the sheets and passed the fuck out!