To agree with another user, we know absolutely nothing about what the roommates did or did not see, who exactly was on the phone, etc. All we know is the police were called for an “unconscious person” (could be a victim, but could also be a roommate that fainted), that the call was made from inside the home, and it was made from a roommate’s phone, but not necessarily the roommate speaking to dispatch.

That above is all factual and backed up in the police report. However, if we want to turn some wheels in an attempt to figure out what actually happened, I will reference a YouTube video I saw earlier today on r/MoscowMurders, which has since been deleted, as it is not backed up by any proof. Rightfully so. I want to preface, beforehand, that I take the video with a grain of salt, because I am all for logic, and leaving the feds and LE to figure this out. Not us.

I typed out a whole explanation of the video here, but deleted it as I believe someone will think I’m trying to spread rumors. So, I won’t explain the video, per se, but I will give my 2 cents on why I don’t think any doors were locked and what I think happened, using the factual info from the police report, the coroner, and the non-confirmed info from the YT video.

I think what happened was the roommates went upstairs, to the second floor, and found E, laying in the floor, by the bed (I want to say that’s what the coroner later said, that someone was on the floor, but I can’t recall). The door would have to be open to see this upon entering the second floor. They noticed he wasn’t responsive, saw blood pooled around him, and went to call 911 to report the horrific scene. However, the gruesome scene sent them into shock, so they ran outside in hysterics (after dialing 911 inside, stated by police report) and fainted. The video mentioned when the roommates’ friends were “summoned” (police report used that terminology), but I can’t remember if it was before or after discovering E. Either way, (still speculating while using the true and maybe not true info I’ve read) the 2 roommates and the friends were outside the house. People who were outside saw the commotion and the unconscious roommate, came over, and picked up the phone, noticing 911 was on the line. They talked to dispatch and said someone had fainted. This could explain the call being put under “unconscious person”, and not homicide, until after EMS arrived.

The video also explains why and how the scene became contaminated, as one source I read said it was. It does go into more detail about that morning, but I’ll leave that to the people who want to watch the video on YT. I read the community rules, and didn’t see if it said I can’t reference where to find it, so I apologize if I missed that. But if you would like to watch it, it’s on YT and you can search “Idaho 911 Call” and it’s posted by Harsh Reality. It helps understand what possibly happened that morning, and, if true, why I highly highly doubt the surviving roommates had any involvement. Which I did come to that conclusion before the video, but if it’s true, would prove that.

Sorry for the long winded post! I just haven’t seen anyone talk about this video, and it really got me thinking about the 911 call, and would like to see what others think.

TL;DR - I don’t think the doors were locked, due to seeing a video, stating a person who was there that morning sent in a letter of what happened that morning the 911 call was made. The video is NOT confirmed to be true. Just throwing out what I think happened while using facts from the police report, coroner, and this video, combined.

EDIT: I see that some commenters already referenced some of what I mentioned above, however, this comment can give some insight on where they might have gotten their info.