Since not everyone has gotten to hear Fillet Show, this exercise will exclude that album.

E2K has 9 tracks YPAA has 9 tracks DIH has 10 tracks Inlet has 8 tracks

Build the perfect Hum album with 10 tracks, keeping the same slotting from the songs original album

Everyone will have The Scientists from DIH as track 10. I don’t think there will be many arguments here.

Everyone will have only three choices of Winder, Songs of Departure and Farewell, and Apollo as track 9.

Then, build the perfect album from all 4 albums.

No bonus tracks. Sorry!

Mine would be

1. Isle of the Cheetah (DIH)
2. The Pod (YPAA)
3. Stars (YPAA)
4. Suicide Machine (YPAA)
5. Afternoon With the Axolotls (DIH)
6. Green To Me (DIH)
7. I’d Like Your Hair Long (YPAA)
8. Shapeshifter (Inlet)
9. Winder (E2K)
10. The Scientists (DIH)

There are some tough choices here, no doubt. I realllllllly wanted Desert Rambler in #3 but couldn’t deny Stars it’s rightful place on this album.

Thoughts? Objections?