I posted here a little while ago about my girl's first orgasm and how the guy who gave it to her somehow seemed to know exactly what she was feeling and even figured out that she had never cum before as he was bringing her to her first climax (https://www.reddit.com/r/hotpast/comments/1b521rx/the_guy_who_gave_my_girl_her_first_orgasm_ever/).

Well, I got a lot of DMs and questions from lots of people here regarding that post, so I thought I'd make a follow up. First, let me clarify that the reason I know such precise specifics about what my girl moaned/cried out and what the guy said to her is because I was actually in the room next door when it happened. And no, my girl and I were not a couple at the time, so it still counts as Hot Past and not cuckolding or cheating etc.

So with that out of the way, the main thing I wanted to post about today was what my girl has told me directly about that moment. I had an in depth conversation with her about it and asked her a whole lot of questions, so I'm just going to post that conversation here as a dialogue script basically, just writing it as accurately as I can remember. These will be pretty much her and my exact words, but I can't promise my memory is 100% perfect, but I will say this is not a conversation I would forget easily, so I am confident in saying that this is a pretty accurate recount:

Me: So, I've been thinking about your first orgasm a lot lately.

Her: [Sarcastic tone] Oh yeah...

Me: Haha, yeah, and I'd really like to ask you some more about it, coz I really just want to get some things straight in my mind about it.

Her: [Understanding tone] Sure.

Me: Ok, so, you know how you screamed "what the fuck?" at him right?

Her: [Embarrassed tone] Yeah?"

Me: Was that when your orgasm was first starting to build?

Her: Yeah. I mean, I didn't know that's what it was at the time, but yeah.

Me: So what were you thinking and feeling in that moment?

Her: Look, I can't lie, it felt really good what he was doing, but then I felt like all this pressure started to build up and I got scared. I didn't know if I was gonna pee myself or if something was gonna to break, I could just feel all this pressure and I was afraid, so I was just asking him for reassurance I spose.

Me: So it felt like something was gonna break? So then, it was feeling like something was wrong?

Her: Just felt like something I'd never experienced before, so my natural instinct was to panic and think something was wrong, but it actually felt good. Like, REALLY good, but still scary for me.

Me: So when did you realise that it was actually an orgasm building up and not something else?

Her: Honestly, not until he told me that's what it was. Even then, I was still in shock and it didn't hit me that's what it was right away. It was only after he said he could tell I'd never cum before and then told me that I was about to that it really sunk in that's what he was doing to me.

Me: How did you feel and what were you thinking after you realised what was happening?

Her: Still scared, and a bit embarrassed. I mean, I only just met the guy that night and I was already feeling embarrassed about the sounds and faces he'd got me making up till then, and now I knew I was close to having my first orgasm and had no idea what kind of an idiot I was gonna make of myself if it actually did hit me. But I was excited too of course, and kinda, I dunno, grateful I guess. Like, in that moment, I felt very appreciative of him and grateful he had gotten me as close to an orgasm as I was even at that point.

Me: Did you know it was about to happen just before it happened?

Her: No, I had no idea how much the pressure would build before it would actually happen. I just felt it keep building and building and didn't know when it would stop.

Me: So what were you feeling and thinking just before it happened then?

Her: Still very scared and embarrassed, I felt kinda, I dunno, helpless I guess, and overwhelmed...

Me: Is that why you cried out to him?

Her: Yeah, I dunno, I felt so vulnerable, I just needed support. I needed to know someone was there for me, so I dunno, I guess I just cried out to him since he was the one there doing this to me. It was so good how he talked me through it, it helped a lot, especially when he told me he had me, that made me feel a bit less scared and embarrassed, and when he warned me I was about to pop, that's exactly how I felt, like something was about to pop, so it reassured me a lot that I knew he knew exactly how I was feeling.

Me: So when you got your orgasm, when it hit, you had no idea it was coming until literally it hit you?

Her: Nope, not a clue. It got me totally by surprise. I mean, I guess I did have some clue it was gonna happen soon coz he did tell me I was about to bust, but like I said, I just felt more and more pressure building and didn't know when it was gonna release till it actually did.

Me: And when your orgasm actually did hit, what were you thinking and feeling then?

Her: Like, when I actually had the orgasm, what was I thinking and feeling the moment it started?

Me: Yeah.

Her: Oh, well I kinda lost the ability to think if I'm being honest. I really couldn't say that I was THINKING anything. I just remember suddenly feeling this huge release down there, like when you finally pee after holding it way too long but obviously a lot more intense and like, WAY better, like, actual pleasure rather than relief.

Me: Do you remember how loud you screamed?

Her: [Embarrassed tone] Yeah, I know.

Me: Were you trying not to be so loud and just couldn't help it? Or did you just decide to let go?

Her: Um, I guess...I'll have to explain. So as it was building and after I knew what it was, the thought did occur to me that some girls scream super loud when they have orgasms, and I didn't want to be like those girls. I didn't want to be that lame and attention seeking. So as it was building, I did have every intention of controlling myself and trying to keep the noise to a minimum. When it actually hit though and I felt that sudden huge release all at once, I wasn't even thinking about anything. I couldn't. So I just reacted how I reacted. So it's not like I decided to just let go, but in the moment it wasn't like I tried to control it either, coz it got me by such surprise.

Me: But if you had tried to control it, do you think you could have?

Her: No, I wouldn't have been able to help it.

Me: It just felt that good?

Her: [Embarrassed tone] Yeah, it did.