Josi for sure, he had more points on a way worse team and pretty much carried his goalie to a vezina finalist position. Makar hasn't done jack shit in the finals and didn't outperform Josi by any real stat.

If you were an actual hockey fan you'd know the weight of breaking a 30 year no 90 point season mark by 6 points. Last person with 96 points as a dman was Bobby Orr. If that means nothing to you are already to far gone.

Nah dude just go watch him some of his games from this year you. It's just cute arguing with people about something they know nothing about.

Nah r/hockey just doesn't understand how good of a hockey player Josi is and can't stand to reason that there was a better defenceman in the leauge this year over all the Macock sucking going on in this sub.

Fat goose egg stats wise first game in every stat. Big ol -3 in game 3.

Your delusional and you don't watch Josi play hockey. There's no swaying you when all you've been seeing for the past month is Makar getting sucked off by the NHL and ESPN. You've prolly watched josi play hockey 1 or 2 times in your life... go watch him a couple times and get back to me.

This is a LIE, show me these clearly better advanced statistics or "underlying numbers". Yall are just parroting other commenters. I've looked at them and he was not in any fashion wayyyyyyyyy better. Can't wait for tampa to come back and tap that booty so all yall COL fans will shut the fuck up.

Also shittiest take I have ever seen on r/hockey "Josi was sheltered" you're a clown

This whole fucking subreddit is cringe you COL fair weather fan. Prolly don't even know who Claude lemuix is. Not talking to your non existent hockey knowledge ass. Pzpz

Bro show us these stats. Cite one of them. You guys are lying through your teeth.

Bro you just started watching hockey stfu. You don't know shit. Go back to only watching football. I'd also refrain from talking about hockey with people in real life unless you want to be laughed at.

Show me these stats. Because I've looked and out of all the advanced statistics they split all of them.

Bro idk what you COL bros don't fucking get. Josi isn't even an offensive defenseman... the crack must be good in Denver.

Everyone from COL acting like he's a Karlsson type of defenseman he's not. You talk shit about his PK ability that's because carrier and ekholm are PK specialists. He is a defensive defenseman who plays on the PP and has a shitty partner as his d pair. If josi had Toews on his blue line this entire year and a much better offensive team (like makar has) he'd have better defensive number. Idk if you watched any preds hockey but other than forsberg and duchy we didn't have much scoring. If josi was on the AVs he would have had the best season in the history of the NHL and what does Makar do with it? Can't even beat a scrub on the preds? Lol get the fuck out of here.

You're an idiot.

You'd be sucking his dick on the ice if he was on the Avs. Josi on the avs this year he'd have 110pts. Keep on keeping on tho with your COL delusions of granduer you all got going on rn.

The mental gymnastics people have to do to not give the best defenceman in 34 years the best dman of the season trophy is astounding.

This is a lie that keeps getting retold. Show me.