When I was in grad school, Craigslist was still a viable way to be slutty and I, a stressed out grad student with some deeply dirty desires, made liberal use of it.

The first person I met off Craigslist was fun if a little awkward, but I had an epiphany before putting up my second ad--why not try to do something from my sexual bucket list?

The top goal of my sexual bucket list at that time was a tie between getting used by two men at once or having a gangbang. But the most important part of it was that I wanted to get used by at least two men at once. More than two if possible, but I would settle for two.

I placed an ad and set aside some time to go through the hundreds of applicants I had in just a day or so. Most of the responses I got weren't what I was looking for or didn't seem like good fits. But then one caught my eye--a man (we'll call him 'James') had reached out to offer me a threesome and also, in case I ended up feeling like the sex wasn't what I expected, he promised me a sweet potato pie too, since pie can fix pretty much anything. Since so many of the people responding to me had such terrible email communication skills, it was pretty exciting to see a response that was funny, respectful, and also seemed to fit what I was looking for.

We scheduled a time to talk on the phone. James was relieved I was actually a hot female grad student like I had said (I gathered this was sometimes not the case for other ads he had answered). James told me he was part of a loose network of friends/acquaintances who would coordinate to set up threesomes, gang bangs and orgies (through what he basically described as a group sex listserv). He had reached out to another man from the group, 'Max,' as the third. Unfortunately no one else was currently available to make the threesome into a full-on gangbang, but James was hopeful that if things went well with the initial threesome, he might be able to get me a gangbang the next time. Even over the phone, James and I vibed well, and he was clearly experienced and committed to making sure group sex was fun and comfortable for everyone involved.

The day of, I was nervous. I had bought a butt plug in preparation and had been using it to stretch out my ass during the days leading up to the threesome. I knew from my pre-threesome meet up with James (perhaps a story for another time) that he had a large cock that took a bit of work to get in my ass, and based on Max's pics, his was also quite big. Both were probably between 7-8 inches and thick--I wasn't used to taking cocks that large, but I really wanted to get fucked in the ass and the pussy at the same time. It would be hard to do, but I could feel my panties dripping at just the thought of it.

James picked me up and brought me to his apartment. Max would be a little late, so we got started. James and I went to his bedroom; he pushed me down on the bed and began to grope my breasts, kissing me deeply. I squirmed, pinned down by his weight and already more turned on than I thought possible. James sat up and kneeled over me. I tried to sit up but he pushed me down and pulled my dress off. He then spread my legs open and tied my ankles to his bedposts, forcing my legs to stay open, and then came back to the front of the bed. He straddled my shoulders and began face fucking me. My open legs and exposed pussy faced his open bedroom door; with my legs tied to the bed, I had no choice but to show myself off to whoever came in immediately as they walked into the room.

James wrapped his hands in my hair, guiding my head as be shoved his cock down my throat. I paced my breathing and tried to not gag on his large cock as he fucked my face. As I eagerly sucked his cock and took it as deep as I could down my throat, I heard the front door open. James didn't stop what he was doing, but called out "Hey Max! In the bedroom." I heard footsteps approach.

James was still kneeling over me, thrusting his cock deep into mouth and throat. My view of the rest of the room was completely blocked by his body as he used my mouth for his own pleasure. Suddenly I felt several fingers gently probing my pussy. One finger, then two, slid in and out of me. Another finger began to gently rub my swollen clit and I groaned in pleasure, mouth still full of James' cock.

"Damn she's wet," I heard a deep voice say; I realized the deep voice and the probing fingers both belonged to Max, as James still had both his hands buried in my hair to hold my head steady as he fucked my mouth. I could feel Max's fingers taking full advantage of the fact that my legs were tied open, leaving my soaking wet pussy utterly exposed to this complete stranger, and I was loving it every second of it. I had never even interacted with Max before the moment I felt his fingers slip inside me, as James had coordinated everything for the threesome by talking to each of us separately. I still couldn't even actually see Max yet, as my vision was blocked by James. When it hit me that a man I had never seen, met, or communicated with before was currently fingering me and there wasn't anything I could do except take it, I almost came from sheer arousal, but then Max slid his fingers out of me one last time, gave my clit a quick lap of his tongue to taste me, and finally addressed me, though I still couldn't see him. "Well, it's nice to meet you, slut. James, let's get her on the ground so she can give both our cocks some attention."

(This got super long, so I'll continue it in a future update!) (Also edits for grammar and readability; clearly writing the first version of this post on my phone while half asleep was a poor choice lol)