“Hey, Thomas! Just a quick video so you can see what your wife has been up to while you’re at your work retreat… “

Liza had started filming herself a couple of feet away, but now flipped her phone’s screen around so it was recording Aubrey and me, angled up from below—Aubrey’s face blushing, since Liza taking a video had caught her off guard, her eyes wide and tits bouncing as I railed into her from behind, my chest and head well out of frame as we fucked on the floodlit cabin deck.

“Oh f-fuck…” she moaned. I felt her pussy clench around me.

“Anyone could be watching,” Liza was saying, still narrating to Thomas and now panning her phone 360 degrees around us, showing the lights on in nearby cabins and the river babbling nearby before returning to Aubrey’s form splayed against the well-lit deck, her body writhing and jerking as I slammed my hips up into hers.

Moving the phone down Aubrey’s body and holding it closer to her, Liza filmed my girthy dick working in and out of her up close. I slowed my strokes for the camera, drawing deep moans from Aubrey as I slid nearly all the way out of her, feeling her grippy lips and lightly scratchy public hair around my tip—and then plunging back in as deep as I could go, until I could feel her lips stretching around the base of my cock and her pubic curls tangle with mine as, deep inside her, my tip brushed against the tight ring of her cervix, leaking precum.

Aubrey’s eyes rolled back and she threw back her head, letting out a guttural moan as I held myself as deep as I could inside of her. Liza moved to stand beside us, just to my right, and brought up the camera to film Aubrey’s face in profile—getting her reactions but angled so my face was nowhere near the shot.

“Does that dick feel good inside you? Stretching you out?” Liza asked.

“Unnnnggghh,” Aubrey could only grunt in satisfaction, nodding, her eyes fluttering as I started to pick up the pace again.

Liza panned down Aubrey’s body again, filming her tits bouncing in profile, her body shuddering with each thrust of my hips, her voluptuous ass slapping as my shaft railed in and out of her glistening pussy lips.

“Holy shit, you can see him in her guts,” Liza said, moving the camera closer. “Pushing her belly out.”

I wasn’t immediately sure what she meant, but (after watching the video later) it turns out you could faintly see Aubrey’s lower belly ripple every time I went all the way inside her.

“You can feel it, too,” she said, placing her hand against Aubrey’s stomach and pressing.

Deep inside of Aubrey, I instantly felt the pressure of Liza’s hand—and she gasped as she could feel the shaft of my dick moving within her friend’s body.

She looked up at me, still filming her hand against Aubrey’s stomach in close up. The sheer “holy shit” horniness that passed between us, in that exchange of eye contact, was enough to send me up to the edge almost instantly.

Liza saw my eyes go wide and felt me start to thrust erratically. She knew I was right there. Her green eyes flashed with mischief.

“This time,” Liza said, still narrating to Thomas, ”he’s going to cum down your wife’s throat.”

Grabbing Aubrey with one hand and filming with the other, she pulled her off my glistening cock and away from me and then spun her around, guiding her to her knees. My shaft throbbed in the night air, right on the verge of cumming… just as Liza guided Aubrey’s mouth onto me.

I gasped, and tried to hold in a moan, as her hot mouth closed around the head of my dick—and then I felt Liza start to push the back of Aubrey’s head, forcing me deeper. I was trying desperately to hold back my orgasm as my tip pushed past my friend’s molars and into her throat, feeling the walls of her throat vibrate lightly as she moaned. Liza pushed as far as she could, until I felt Aubrey’s nose and hot breath against the base of my dick—my entire length throbbing—and then she gagged lightly. Feeling her throat rippling around me, I could hold it no longer and felt my semen start to erupt, spurting hard into the back of her throat.

Immediately Aubrey gagged and snorted and a gob of cum shot out of her left nostril, into my pubes. But Liza held her head against me as my dick spasmed a second time, pumping another thick rope down her throat as she snorted again and a bubble of cum appeared out of her other nostril. Finally Liza released her and she eased herself back, gasping and catching her breath, sperm and saliva dripping from us both as my shaft emerged from her mouth.

Liza held up one hand to catch as much of the cum/saliva mix as possible—and with the other hand was right there with her phone, capturing Aubrey wiping her eyes and smiling in embarrassment and then starting to daintily dab my cum from her nose and lips.

I tried to catch Liza’s eye off-camera, thinking it might be hot if she dipped one of her cum-covered fingers inside of Aubrey’s pussy, but she was way ahead of me—already crouching down and filming herself smearing cum and saliva against Aubrey’s labia, rubbing it on her clit like lube and then working two semen-covered fingers up inside of her.

Silently I came up behind Liza and took the phone out of her hand, freeing her to reach up and squeeze Aubrey’s breast while I took over filming the video for Thomas. Aubrey moaned as Liza brought her face down to lap at her friend’s pussy, but then then after a moment Aubrey pushed her away and pulled both of them down onto the pool chairs (on which they’d apparently fucked earlier) into a 69 position.

I leaned over to get a close up of Liza’s tongue flitting up and down Aubrey’s pussy lips, alternately teasing her and sucking lightly on her clit. This seemed to be driving Aubrey wild, and was already making me hard again, so I lingered and watched and filmed for what felt like a long time.

Then, just as it seemed like Aubrey was getting close to orgasm, I moved up to film her eating Liza out—with a very different technique, sticking her tongue deep inside to taste her, and then running it up and pressing it against her clit, holding it and licking with some pressure. I could still see my cum on her nose and lips, which—I suddenly realized—surely meant she’d accidentally gotten at least a little of my semen all over and inside of Liza’s completely fertile pussy in the course of eating her out.

My head was still swimming from this realization as Aubrey’s breath caught in her throat and she lifter her head from Liza’s pink lips, clenching her jaw.

“I’m c-c-uuunngh—“was all Aubrey managed to get out before her whole body shuddered, Liza licking feverishly as she came hard.

After a second Liza motioned for her phone, so I hit “stop” on the recording as Aubrey came down from her orgasm and handed it over.

I assumed there might be a pause in the action, or that we’d watch the video together before continuing, but Liza hadn’t gotten off yet. After the briefest of pauses to catch her breath, Aubrey resumed eating Liza out with a renewed enthusiasm—so I just sat back for a long moment and watched, trying to savor every detail, my cock throbbing again as Liza got slowly closer and closer.

After a moment Aubrey shifted around for a more comfortable angle, so they were no longer in the 69 position and Liza could lay on her back. This left Aubrey on her stomach in front of me, legs spread slightly, her freshly-fucked and licked pussy lips gaping invitingly…

I got onto the pool chair on my knees and inched forward until my cockhead was pressing against Aubrey’s opening. She stayed focused on Liza’s pussy, barely reacting as I pushed inside her yet again—in pronebone, my weight fully on top of her as I eased in.

Suddenly Liza’s eye’s snapped open and she pulled Aubrey’s head up. I paused, too, holding myself halfway inside of Aubrey.

“Hang on,” Liza said. “I just got an idea.” With that, she jumped up and ran inside the open door a few feet away, still completely naked.

Aubrey and I shrugged at one another but then got up and followed, feeling satisfied that we’d fulfilled our public sex kink, at least for tonight, and curious about what Liza had in mind.

As we walked inside, I gritted my teeth.

“So, uh,” I said. “I think you might’ve gotten a little of this…”

I gestured to indicate Aubrey’s face and nose.

“… In Liza’s pussy, while you were eating her out just now.”

Aubrey was initially confused, but then she put her hand to a spot on the side of her nose, where I’d pointed, and felt a trace of drying cum. Her eyes went wide.

“Oh shit,” she almost laughed. “I didn’t even think about that, but I guess it was all over my face.”

“Yeah,” I laughed too, a little awkwardly.

It turned out Liza had gone into her bedroom. We ran into her in the hall, coming back out of her doorway, all of us stark naked.

“Oh, sorry, I was coming back—but I guess we can move the party inside,” she said.

“Hey, fun twist,” Aubrey said. “I definitely got Scott’s cum all up in you. By total accident. At least a little bit.” She gestured at her face, which was mostly clear but where a few streaks were still obviously drying.

Liza raised an eyebrow and opened her mouth a little, in mild surprise, but didn’t seem especially worried.

“Was it a lot?” she looked down at herself, peeling her lips open. Neither of us could see anything, though we were both more than happy to take a close look. “Like, is that something I should be concerned about, or nah?”

“I mean, probably not?” Aubrey said. “It wasn’t much. But we could always get you some Plan B if you wanna be totally sure.”

Liza shrugged.

“Yeah, that’s probably smart, I guess,” she said. “What even is Plan B? I’ve never fucked around with birth c… oh my god, you must be loving this.”

This last part was directed at me, sardonically, as she caught my eye and (apparently) remembered how much it turned me on to cum inside of someone—which is why I’d asked Aubrey and Tess if they were comfortable getting tested and going raw, back when all of this started. (I’m not sure if it quite rises to the level of a breeding kink—though maybe!—it’s just something that insanely turns me on whenever I can do so safely.)

“What do you mean?” I smirked but tried to play dumb. Liza gestured at my diamond-hard dick.

“I know you get off on creampies or cumming inside or whatever,” she said. “So you must be fucking loving this! That you managed to inseminate me without even having sex with me.”

My cock throbbed and Aubrey reached down to feel it.

“Oh yeah,” she said to Liza.

“I mean, sure,” I said, having to catch my breath a little at Aubrey’s touch. “That’s—uh, yeah, that’s incredibly hot.” A bead of precum started to gather at my tip and the three of us looked at it for a second.

That’s when both Aubrey and I saw it: the silicone clone-a-willy dildo we’d molded from my dick, now fully hardened and set, in Liza’s hand. That’s what she’d jumped up to get.

“Ah,” said Aubrey with a half-grimace. “I was planning to wait for Thomas to play with that, so I’m not sure if… “

“Who said anything about using it on you?” said Liza. “This might be my only chance to take it for a spin before you and Thomas put a whole lot of miles on it.”

Holy shit.

Aubrey’s eyes flashed.

“Be my guest!” she said, arching an eyebrow. “Maybe I can use it on you?”

Liza turned, leading us back into her bedroom and sitting on the edge of her bed.

“Make me feel exactly what he’s doing to you, at the same time,” she said, holding it out to Aubrey but looking at us both.

“You mean like…” Aubrey started to ask, but I was insanely turned on by what Liza wanted—to sorta kinda “simulate” getting fucked by me, with a dildo molded from my dick—so I pushed her forward, so she was bent over against the edge of the bed facing Liza, and started to run my cockhead up and down her swollen lips.

“Like this,” Liza said, jumping up as I pushed Aubrey over and getting into a similar position, on all fours, just in front of Aubrey. Getting the idea, Aubrey spit on the end of the dildo and started to run it up and down Liza’s perfectly pink opening, in perfect sync with what I was doing to her.

This was weird, for sure—and totally improvised by all of us as we went—but there was something insanely hot about pseudo-fucking both of them at the same time, or at least giving Liza some vague sense (in silicone) of what it would feel like to have sex with me, while in actuality she was just having sex with Aubrey.

“Hang on,” Liza said, and there was a brief awkward pause as she jumped up and rooted around in her bag and came back with some warming lube. She applied it to the dildo, fairly liberally, and then offered it to me—so I took it and put a few big drops on the head of my dick.

Then we synced up again: me running my tip against Aubrey, her mimicking the same movement with Liza, while Liza looked back to watch us. Once it seemed like both women could barely take it any longer, I started to ease myself gently inside of Aubrey again—mindful that this time, in a way, I was also “penetrating” Liza, too, who’d never had sex with a man. So I should take it slow.

When Aubrey started to whimper and push back against me, needing more, I pushed a little further inside—and both she and Liza moaned in response.

“Oh fuck,” Liza said, craning her neck to watch Aubrey work my silicone clone inside of her. “He’s s-so w-wide…”

Inside Aubrey’s pussy, my shaft swelled, but I held myself still for a long moment, remembering how I’d always had to pace myself when entering a new partner for the first time. Again, not that I’m insanely pornstar-level huge or anything, just that I need to be careful to go at their pace to avoid causing pain or discomfort.

Aubrey thought I was just teasing her, which was a nice bonus, but I watched Liza’s face and waited until it seemed like she was ready for more before I eased myself deeper—trying to imagine what Liza’s pussy felt like, how it might differ from Aubrey’s, hoping she was enjoying what it would be like to feel me.

Eventually I felt the back of Aubrey’s pussy close in around my tip, so I pushed my pelvis against her hips, pulling her onto me and flexing my dick against her tight walls. She moaned, letting her head loll forward but pushing the dildo all the way inside of Liza, as well.

“H-holy shit,” Liza said, rubbing her clit furiously. “I’m n-not sure I could do this every day…”

“Mmmmm, but don’t you feel so… full?” asked Aubrey, clenching her walls around me. I drew myself slowly out of her and then eased back in, watching Liza’s face as Aubrey mimicked the same movement with the dildo.

“Mmmmm… “ Liza trailed off, rubbing her clit and just enjoying the sensations for a long moment. Then, out of nowhere, she produced one of those clit-sucker vibrator things (apparently she and Aubrey had been using it on each other before I arrived, so she’d had it stashed under her pillow).

“This is crazy hot, and all… but straight sex is just never gonna do it for me,” she said, flicking it on and holding it above her clit. “No offense,” she said, looking at me.

“None taken,” I smiled back, still insanely turned on and not offended in the least.

For what seemed like a long moment, I pumped away at Aubrey’s pussy, watching her work the dildo in and out of Liza while the latter held the clit sucker to her little pearl—throwing her head back as her pleasure ratcheted higher, her breath coming more and more raggedly.

“Fuck, you feel so good inside me,” Aubrey moaned as we all picked up the pace.

“Y-yes you d-do…” moaned Liza breathlessly as she held the humming toy on her clit. Watching her pussy clench around the dildo shaped like me was driving me wild.

“You should let him cum in you,” Aubrey said suddenly, in a different tone. “For real.”

Liza’s eyes shot open and I almost stopped thrusting in surprise.

“Um, w-what? No,” Liza asked.

Equally surprised, my cock throbbing at the mere suggestion, I felt a little lightheaded all of a sudden.

“Only if you want! But he’s already inseminated you, like you said. So you’re gonna need a Plan B anyway.”

I kept thrusting idly, but otherwise didn’t dare move a muscle.

“Yeah…”

“So, if it’s the one and only time in your life, why not make it count?”

She seemed to be considering this, sort of indifferently—without any particular interest.

“I mean, it just doesn’t do anything for…”

“But you know it would be like, instant top sexual bucket list experience for him.” She inclined her head in my direction. “Just a thought!”

Oh my god, did I ever owe her.

Liza looked up at me, seeming almost clinically indifferent.

“Is the cleanup annoying? Obvs I’ve never… “

“Nah, I prefer it to being cummed on—you just go to the bathroom afterwards and… “ Aubrey said.

Just the topic of discussion between the two of them was pushing me close to cumming. So I momentarily stopped and pulled out of Aubrey and held my dick for a second to stop myself from going over the edge, looking up a little pathetically at the two women as I did so.

At that, both of them burst into good-natured laughter.

“Oh. My. God,” said Liza, removing the sex toy and just laughing for a second. “The look on his face!”

“Like a puppy,” Aubrey giggled, beside herself. “Or a kid on Christmas.”

“Oh man, how can I say no and crush his dreams?” Liza said, as they both started to compose themselves. Looking at me, she continued: “Do not penetrate me. Got it? Dildos are fun but I’m no less gay than I was before.”

I nodded, trying to keep from passing out.

“But if it blows your mind forever to like put it at the opening while you cum… like she said, I guess I need to take Plan B anyway,” Liza said. “For the first and only time in my life. So somebody might as well enjoy it.”

I nodded and started to reply, but Liza looked down at herself and spread her pussy lips open expectantly, then looked up at me… and I was already close. So that look, offering me her inviting pink insides, was all it took.

“OK, I’m gonna—”

Aubrey caught my tone and got out of the way, pushing me forward as Liza’s eyes widened, a curious smirk playing across her lips, as she held her pussy lips open. Jerking myself with my right hand, Aubrey guided me in front of Liza—and Liza and I looked at each other for a moment, suddenly focused sexually on one another when we’d only ever worried about the other person we were “playing” with.

Gingerly, with all three of us watching closely, I kept jerking my cock… and slowly, slowly inched forward, eventually bringing my tip within half an inch of her spread lips.

Then I leaned forward, still jerking, and let my precum-covered tip just barely make contact with Liza’s hooded clit. We both gasped, feeling a shock like electricity.

“Oh my g-god…” I trailed off, holding my cockhead against her clit and continuing to jerk myself off. She started to writhe at the sensation. Her pussy felt slick and white-hot and I was super aware of the fact that she’d never had sex with a man before.

“Remember, don’t penetrate me…”

But that was all she was able to say before I started to cum—so I moved my tip slightly lower, pressing it against Liza’s quivering pussy lips, which had never been parted by any dick, and felt my vision blur and my balls contract in extreme pleasure as I pumped the first thick rope of cum into her quivering opening.

Over my shoulder, Aubrey gasped as she watched, and I felt her fingers against my balls and taint as she helped work me through the cascading pleasure of an almost painfully intense orgasm.

I started to spurt a second time just as the first gob of cum began to dribble out of Liza’s pussy, so out of instinct she moved herself down a little—and I felt my cockhead nestle snugly past her lips and into her opening, my tip probing into her white-hot insides as my shaft spasmed and pumped another rope of semen, this one deep inside her vagina.

Looking down as I spurted again, she saw that she’d engulfed my tip with her lips and shrugged.

“Obviously you needed to penetrate me more than THAT, dude,” she looked at me with horny amusement as I finished spasming breathlessly against her, not daring to push any deeper but savoring the fact that my tip was feeling a pussy that had never experienced a dick before.

I hadn’t cum all that much, in terms of volume—having fucked both Tess and Aubrey earlier, I was getting pretty close to spent, and both my dick and those muscles that convulse hardest with every orgasm had become a little sore. But feeling my cockhead nestled against our lesbian friend’s opening, her face bemused as I pulled back to watch a moderate load of my semen stream out of her as I withdrew, remains one of the singular hottest moments/experiences of my life. (Obviously I changed both Aubrey and Liza’s names, but they both know how grateful I am to them for embracing my creampie kink and making such a stupid/unlikely fantasy come true during the same weekend they were doing so much wish fulfillment for themselves).

We all took a long moment to catch our breaths and come down, but then Liza produced her phone and handed it to me.

“A one-off, for both of us,” she said, nodding for me to snap a few photos of my cum dripping out of her pink insides as she spread them for the camera. “That’s definitely the closest I’ll ever come to straight sex. No offense.”

“Again, none taken,” I laughed, my head still swimming.

After I was done snapping photos, Liza clicked the clit sucker back on and brought it down—but Aubrey wrenched it out of her hands and started using it on her, making her gasp and occasionally fight against too much sensation, which Aubrey playfully resisted. I just sat back at watched, trying to savor the weekend we’d just given one another and enjoying my friends getting each other off again.

After Liza came, we collapsed into a long cuddle, then retreated to our rooms to shower and freshen up before all falling asleep on the couch watching a movie. That was it for the cabin weekend, and we all had breakfast, then made a quick stop at a pharmacy for Plan B.

A funny aside that will be relevant later: the pharmacy had had both 1-packs and 2-pack of emergency birth control. Each pill still cost like $50, so I was just going to buy a 1-pack (obviously), but then both Aubrey and Liza started half-mockingly saying I should just spring for the second one now, since someone around me—though definitely not Liza—would surely need one soon. I joked with them, but then figured it might genuinely be nice to have a spare Plan B around. So I went for the 2-pack… and it was only as the middle-aged male pharmacist was ringing me up, avoiding eye contact, that I realized he must think I was buying one each for Liza and Aubrey, who were standing on either side of me at the register.

We cracked up about this in the parking lot, then cheers-ed an insane weekend with our coffees as Liza took her contraception. Then we hugged and split up for the drive back into the city.

Aubrey and I kept up a fairly constant stream of texting about all this, but it wasn’t until a few weeks later that she asked me something more direct—a question I’d been hoping she might get around to at some point.

AUBREY: hey random q

ME: Fire away

AUBREY: was thinking abt you cumming in Liza, etc.

ME: I also think about that… a lot

AUBREY: hahaa, naturally

AUBREY: anyway was wondering—what else is on YOUR bucket list??

AUBREY: like this has all been my stuff and I guess Liza’s except for that one thing, and obvs I wanna keep working on my list, but

AUBREY: it occurred to me tht I owe you and it would be fun to check off some stuff on yours next

I told her I’d have to think about it. But I didn’t have to think for long.