When I was 26M, I bought my first home and it happened to be a mile from a college campus. I would hit the local bars some nights and occasionally get a college girl home. But one night during a snowstorm I decided to post on the dating section of Craigslist (when they still had it) about looking for a friend to cuddle & watch Christmas movies.

To my surprise, I got an almost immediate response. She was a junior at the college, and we exchanged a few messages, then moved to text. She seemed shy, and mentioned she was "bigger". When she sent a pic, she really meant she was tall at 6'1". I'm 5'10", and had now problem with her height, especially since she was a redhead... my weakness. An hour later she was on my couch, having shown up in comfy sweats, and I was dressed the same. We watched Elf, but we were making out before Buddy even go to NY.

When my hand went up her sweatshirt, I was pleasently surprised to find she was braless. When I commented, she said "I figured you wanted a hook-up when you posted about cuddling, so why wear underwear." With that, I put my hand down her pants, and sure enough, she was pantyless. I took that as an opportunity to start rubbing her pussy, feeling a small bush. I didn't say anything, but I was so hoping that she had a fire crotch, and I couldn't wait to see it. As she got wetter, I slid a finger into her, and then two. She had me pause so she could remove her sweatshirt and she had the palest tits covered in freckles, with big pink nipples. Her breasts were big, but looked average on her bigger frame.

"Suck my nipples. They get so sensitive."

I started gentle, but then would start pulling them with my teeth and she would moan so hard, pushing my head into her chest. Now I was putting 3 fingers in her sopping gash.

Just as I was about to suggest moving to the bedroom her phone rang. She made me stop because it was her father's ringtone.

He had just gotten home from work and was concerned she wasn't home, especially with the storm going. He insisted she come home NOW. She apologize, said "I love you daddy, I'll be home soon." I didn't realize it until later, but she was a local girl that went to the local college.

I knew she was leaving, so I licked my fingers and commented how I wish I had gotten a chance to taste her, but I'll just smell my fingers and jerk off.

"I'm so sorry. My dad gets really protective. If you can cum quick, I'll can blow you."

I pulled down my sweatpants down enough to have my hard cock spring out and she leaned over and went to down. I played with her tits, and continued to finger her. When I looked at her ass in the air, there was a noticeable wet spot in the crotch of her sweatpants.

A few minutes later, I didn't even try to hold back and asked if I could cum on her tits. I stood up and she pushed her tits together and I jerked off all over them. I leaned down to kiss her, and said I'll grab her a towel.

When I came back in the room, she already had her sweatshirt on and said she had to go, but hopefully we could see each other soon. I jerked off again later smelling my fingers, and thinking about her going home to her father with a wet spot in her pants and tits covered in cum.

We would finally meet up one more time and finally fucked, but then I started getting followed by the cops, and pulled over twice. The last time it was the assistant police chief... who was her father. He wasn't a fan of a 26 year old man fucking his 21 year old daughter. In no uncertain terms, I was never to see her again. Part of me wanted to do it out of spite, but when I texted her to let her know that I can't see her anymore, she simply responded with "My dad got to you, didn't he? It always happens. I understand. Sorry."

​