My wife (Lillie) and I started exploring the swingers lifestyle a year after we were dating. We had a few hits with successful nights out getting drinks with other couples, in group meetups and one on one with another couple. We also had some misses with a night at Checkmate in NYC and meeting a few duds but overall we learned a lot about what we wanted and were enjoying the adventure.

Our main source of connecting with couples was SLS or 3nder (now Feeld). Our introduction to the thought of sex parties was via a couple, Angie and Gio, who we connected with on 3nder. They asked us if we had ever been to a sex party and admitted we had no idea where to even start to attend one. Angie was a short brunette with a voluptuous frame and Gio looked like a typical Williamsburg hipster, bearded, bald with glasses and plenty of tattoos. They began to describe a party called Chemistry that’s typically in Brooklyn and sent us an article from Thrillist about the parties. The parties prioritized consent, female led play and a welcoming atmosphere.

Lillie was nervous about participating in an orgy so she reached out to Angie to get more details about the party and after a few more conversations between us about testing these waters, we decided to apply for membership to Chemistry with Angie and Gio as our reference. After a week we were accepted and the next party was 80/90s neon themed. We were excited, nervous and looking forward to what was ahead for us.

We decided to go to their cocktail mixer, Foreplay the Wednesday before the party despite Angie and Gio being unavailable to come. We went and got drinks and met two other couples. The first was a super fit Italian couple in their 40s, Francesca and Tony. Francesca was so fit she looked like she competed in strongman competitions. Tony had an athletic build and a few inches shorter than me at 5’10. The other couple was Andra and Michael. Andra was a petite Asian female and Michael was an athletic white male about 5’8.

We connected with Francesca and Tony the most and the girls really hit it off with innocent flirting and Francesca kept brushing Lillie’s thighs. I could tell they were enjoying themselves and talked about the possibility of meeting up at the party on Saturday.

Saturday came and we were super nervous for the party. We went to the venue about an hour after doors opened, which was at a warehouse in Williamsburg. We brought a joint and decided to smoke it to loosen up and we bought a bottle of Tito’s for the party since the event is byob. Lillie was wearing a Nike sports bra, with a half tee shirt with a stretched collar over it, with bright neon biker shorts. I also went the workout route as we looked like extras in the movie Flashdance.

We walked in just as a sexy performance by a burlesque artist was on stage. We brought our bottle to the bar, put our name on the bottle and got ourselves a drink as we looked around at the venue. We looked up at a loft area and noticed an Asian couple fucking doggy style looking out onto the dance floor. Lillie and I looked at each other and raised our eyebrows in unison.

We met up with Angie and Gio and Angie was smoking her weed vape pen and shared it with us. Angie was wearing a skin tight neon dress to accentuate her big breasts and Gio was wearing short shorts, a band shirt and jean jacket with a sweatband over his head. We chatted for a little bit while watching the performances and Lillie pulled me down to her level to ask me if I wanted to check out the play area. We looked at the small loft area above the dance floor and it looked a little crammed so we headed upstairs to the other play area.

We walked up a spiral staircase and said hi to the party monitor making sure all men were accompanied by their partner. As we got past the checkpoint we saw undressed couples occupying a wall full of beds with mattresses on the floor across the middle with bench seating opposite the beds. Some couples were caressing each other and watching the action but our eyes caught a threesome between a tall, skinny white guy with a very large dick, his petite wife with a pixie cut and their girlfriend a curvy, tattooed brunette with glasses. The girlfriend was sucking his dick as the petite wife caressed the girlfriend’s breasts. Lillie grabbed my arm and got closer as she enjoyed what she was seeing while I looked around for a spot and found one in the back at one of the last beds.

We walked by the threesome and the girlfriend looked up at us and smiled as she took the large dick out of her mouth and held it in her hand to take a break. Lillie and I sat down on the bed and quickly undressed and started making out. I worked my hand down from her breasts down to her clit and started lightly rubbing Lillie to work her up and it was unbelievable how wet she was. Lillie told me she needed my mouth between her legs and I quickly obliged and I got on my knees next to the bed and Lillie crawled over to the edge and grabbed my head to pull between her thighs.

As I started licking Lillie, a curvy black girl with big curly black hair named Taylor asked her if she could join us. Lillie said please and gasped as Taylor pushed her back down on the bed and started sucking her nipples. I went back to working my tongue up and down Lillie’s lips as she got wetter and wetter. It didn’t take long for Lillie to start tightening up before shaking as she orgasmed from the over stimulation from Taylor and my tongues. Lillie tried to catch her breath and started laughing as she shared a kiss with Taylor as Taylor went back to the couple she was playing with before.

Lillie brought me in for a kiss before quickly turning my head to point out an open spot in the middle of the mattresses on the floor. We left our clothes there and went over to the spot. Lillie started sucking my dick as I began growing in her mouth. Out of the corner of my eye, I could see Angie crawling over to where we were. Gio was gently fucking the petite wife with the pixie cut from the threesome and Angie wanted to find others to play with. Angie finally made it over, smiled at us and asked Lillie if she could taste my dick. Lillie looked at me and I gave her a look that probably screamed “yes, please”. Lillie said yes and Angie grabbed my hard dick and put her mouth over it and started working the shaft.

Angie hiked up her dress and looked at me with my dick in her mouth that said please touch me. She nodded her head and I reached my hand down and grabbed her thick breasts before working my hand down to her panties. I pushed her panties aside and started fingering her slit and felt how damp she was. Lillie was rubbing my thigh and replaced Angie on my dick as Angie lifted up onto her knees and pulled out her breasts and I worked my fingers deeper inside Angie.

Angie looked at Lillie and asked if she could fuck me but Lillie said no as she told me later that she was waiting for a true full swap and since Gio was occupied, it wasn’t in the cards. I was disappointed but I understood and continued fingering Angie before she decided to move on since she couldn’t fuck me.

Lillie asked if we could take a break, go downstairs and get water/a drink. We went to collect our clothes from underneath a couple watching the sea of moaning bodies, and I looked at my phone and noticed it wasn’t even midnight and knew there was a lot more fun in store for the night.

Part 2 coming soon.