(I posted this previously but have rewritten a lot of it to make it a better read. All details remain the same, just better worded. Names changed for privacy)

I was 20 and it was a fraternity formal. For those who weren’t in Greek life, a formal is a once-per-semester event where the fraternity has a weekend long retreat/party in another city and everyone brings dates. At least that’s how my fraternity did it. This particular formal was held in a huge cabin and I brought a girl that had been to a lot of our parties and events in the past. She honestly wasn’t that attractive, but everyone had to bring someone and she was an easy ask. We didn’t spend much time together that weekend.

It’s pretty common for people to hookup with other people’s dates. Unless the date is the actual partner of one of the brothers, everyone is fair game. Enter Lauren. She was tall (maybe 5’10” or so), tan, brown hair, nice b-cups, and an impressive ass. She was the date of a brother who had absolutely zero chance of hooking up with her, so that made her well liked by all the guys. She wasn’t very outgoing or flirty when sober, but alcohol completely changed her, and there was plenty of booze at the cabin that would soon transform her into an entirely different person.

It was the first of two nights and she hit the booze hard like everyone else. After getting thoroughly intoxicated, she started kissing whoever she could find. They weren’t all make outs. In fact most were just quick kisses. I suppose she made it her mission to kiss as many of us as she could, and some of us took more advantage of that then others.

She made out with one brother (let’s call him Andrew) who coaxed her into a bedroom that happened to be assigned to me. It was right off of the dining room area on the second floor where about half of the people were gathered. Andres was undeniably attractive. Although he was less than average height (maybe 5’6” or 5’7”. I’m 6’3”, so I have a hard time gauging how tall someone that short is) he was very handsome and had a lean, fit physique. He had great arms(although not that large) and I specifically remember how defined they looked in the cutoff shirt he was wearing. He was sorta blue-collar, had a nice natural tan, and short, rather attractive facial hair.

I met him on the stairs as he was coming down and I was going up when he told me what had happened. He said something to the effect of “hey man, just wanted to give you a heads up that Lauren blew me in your room. There’s no mess or anything, just wanted to let you know.” This didn’t feel unusual or anything, it just felt like he was telling me so I didn’t hear it from someone else first. I didn’t mind at all and actually thought it was pretty sexy, since I found them both very attractive.

So the drinking continued and Lauren continued to kiss or make out with everyone she could. When it was my turn, she was making out with one brother on a couch. At this point I had not kissed her or even touched her at all. When they stopped rather suddenly, she grabbed my hand and pulled me (gently) down to the couch as I passed by. I was shy and had zero flirting skills, so this sort of advance was unexpected, but highly welcomed. She started kissing me and placed her hand on my thigh. As you guys will know, there is nothing that can take you from 0 to 60 like a girl putting her hand on the inside of your thigh. We made out for what seemed like a long time before I decided to take make the next move. I stood up and took her by the hand and led her to the bathroom nearby for some privacy.

After I locked the door, things got really fun. She was wearing a black mid-thigh dress that tightly showed her nice figure. As we were making out, we backed us up toward the sink counter and took a seat. I started to get handsy and felt up her breasts. She assisted by pulling down her dress giving me full access. The booze made her very talkative, and slurring, she called me by several other fraternity brothers names before landing on the right one. This made it clear to me that it wasn’t necessarily me she wanted, she just wanted literally anyone, but I didn’t care. In fact, I found it hot that she listed off several of the sexier brothers before saying my name. Maybe her mind was on the other guys?

Things progressed. My hands travelled south and I placed my hand over her puss over her thongs, sneaking a finger underneath. While she drunkenly moaned, she started to run the bulge in my pants. Right before she reached in to pull out my dick, she drunkenly blurted out “let’s see if you are bigger than Andrew.” This seemed exciting to me, and being bigger than average (6.5”) and physically much taller than Andrew, I kind of expected to outsize him and maybe impress her. She reached in, grabbed me and nonchalantly said:

“Nope.”

I smirked and we got back to business. In my mind though, I was so fucking turned on. I loved the thought that she had blown a bigger cock just an hour or two before. I loved picturing her taking his bigger cock down her throat. Part of me hoped that someone outside the door had heard and learned that I was sexually inferior to him. It was thrilling and I wanted to know more, but I wasn’t going to stop what was going on to find out. She dropped to the floor and blew me before we fucked on the counter. There was no chance in hell I was going to finish since I was way too drunk to orgasm, but we fucked for a while until someone knocked at the door. We then got dressed and departed. She continued to drink and kiss some more guys. I went on drinking too, feeling incredible.

That girl and I hooked up dozens of time since. She was sort of a FWB for maybe a semester and a half. Of course, I had to learn more about her experience with Andrew. She told me after making out for a while, the pulled her into my bedroom and down into his lap. He then started complimenting her appearance and told her about how good he was at eating pussy. She said something to the effect of “I know you are trying to get me to fuck you” and apparently she didn’t want to go that far with him. I’m not sure why, maybe because he was a “bro” type and she didn’t want to give him the satisfaction, idk. He convinced her to give him a bj though and said that he would eat her out afterward. When he slid his his pants off, a huge dick flung out. She was surprised by his size and said something like “Damn Andrew” before taking him into her hands, and her mouth soon after. She mentioned mentioned to me how he was a struggle to blow because of both his length and girth. I specifically recalling her say that she could not fit her hand all the way around his shaft and that he made her jaw sore from stretching. He was the biggest she had ever saw, and at this point she had probably fooled around with a dozen or so guys. To this day, I jerk off to the thought of them often and the way she so casually said “nope.” The humiliation was incredible.

TL;Dr: a girl told me, at a fraternity formal, that I was smaller than my fraternity brother who she had blown earlier that night.

Dms open.