Another one of my favourite times that I posted somewhere on Reddit a while back. Never hurts to revive hot stories.

---
Not sure if this counts as cheating but still pretty fucking hot so thought I’d share. My bf and I had had a few too many glasses of wine and invited a guy over for some oral play. My bf said he wasn’t really up for anal but cock is cock and I love swallowing as much as I love being bred so I was like sure why not.

The guy came over, we started making out and took him up to the bedroom undressing along the way. He was average bodied on the slim side with a bit of a furry chest and bush and a nice 7 inch uncut cock. He also had a number of tattoos on his body which were… fuck he was just sexy! And so it didn’t much for me to drop to my knees and take his growing cock in my mouth, slowly moving up and down to get it wet, taking the time to spend on his musky hairy balls and then back up to his head poking out from under the somewhat tight foreskin. My bf dropped down on his knees next to me and we sucked the guy together for a bit, and swapped positions around. At one time, the guy was fucking my face while he blew my bf. I was still a bit tipsy and I wanted that cock in me so bad that I whispered to him that I wanted him inside me… my bf didn’t hear me but this guy pulled his rock hard cock out of my mouth, pushed my legs back and started digging his face right into my hole, rimming me out. My bf moved down to blow the guy and I guess the guy thought my bf was getting his cock ready for my hole so when it was wet he moved up and put his tip against my hole and started pushing in.
Here’s the thing. My bf isn’t really that cool with me getting fucked by others unless in the rare occasion that he’s in the mood to see that happen and so he told the guy we are just looking for oral and the guy stopped. We all blew and rimmed each other some more until I swallowed both their loads.

It was pretty late at night and we were all so tired, so we offered for the guy to stay over and he said he’d love to. We made room for him in between my bf and I and I cuddled up against him, feeling his hairy chest, taking in that now sweaty and musky post-sex smell off of him. He felt good and we dozed off.

Im a side sleeper and must have turned to my side facing away from him because I woke up with the guy almost but not really spooning me. There was some distance between us but he had a finger between my cheeks rubbing my hole lightly. My bf was clearly asleep judging by his deep breath and light snoring. I don’t think that this guy knew I was awake and could feel his finger so I stuck my ass back towards him, scooting closer. He got the hint and started pushing his finger against my hole as I let out a soft moan (it felt good and I wanted to see if my bf was awake). Hearing no change in his breathing, I brought the guy’s hand up to my mouth, licked and got his middle finger wet and moved it back to my hole. He obliged and snuck that finger inside me, slowly moving it around and feeling the edges of my hole. Fuck it was driving me crazy and making me leak so much pre cum!

I couldn’t take it anymore - I had to take him inside me! I quietly reached around to my nightstand to grab the bottle of lube, pumped some out on my hand and found his cock. I looked back at him to show him I wanted him. He jerked his head towards my bf, still deep asleep. I guess he was hinting that my bf didn’t want this to happen. My response to that was sliding to his now wet cock and taking the head of his bare cock inside me. I knew he was turned on because of the way his cock jumped as he grabbed my hips and pulled me onto it. Not only was he fucking me without my bf literally sleeping next to us, but I had him bare inside me. He was so hard. I could tell this was turning him on.

We stayed like that for a good while with him only slightly thrusting or me so as not to wake up my bf. It was becoming clear though that he wanted to shoot a load but we couldn’t because it would wake my bf up. He pulled out and pretending to have just woken up asked me (intentionally loudly) in a sleepy voice where the bathroom was and if he could get some water. My bf woke but before he could reply, I said yeah sure I’ll come down with you. I’m thirsty too. I asked my bf if he needed anything and he asked me to bring some water up for him. I took the guy down the stairs to the kitchen.

We never made it to the kitchen. As we passed the living room, the guy had my chest pinned against the wall and was in me in an instant. He grabbed my hips and fucked and pounded so hard but making sure we weren’t loud. We didn’t have much time but thankfully he was was already edged from my hole earlier and leaking that it didn’t take long for him to put his face against my ear to tell me how turned on this whole thing was making him and that he’s going cum. Squeezing his hands around me, he grunted and made a last few thrusts as he let his seed flow deep in my hole.

He pulled out and wiped his cock but I left my hole as is when we went upstairs with glasses of water. I wanted to keep feeling the lube and cum on my ass!

My bf was asleep but woke up when we got back. He drank his water and asked us to get back in bed. We assumed the same sleeping position as the first time, with me cuddled up against him… this time though, a little scooted up on my pillow so his hand could reach my ass. We fell asleep as he slid his finger into my hole feeling how much he opened me and feeling his cum in me.

The next morning before he left, the three of us played a bit again (oral) but it definitely wasn’t as much fun as the night.