I bought both, so you don't have to.

Reviewing both and judging based on my personal preference.

Photo Comparison

Liberator 139.99$USD

Meiki 229.95$USD

Liberator Easy to clean, Inside can be inverted to clean also. I use the disposable bleach paper towels. More discrete (the square end poking out under the bed isnt eye catcing). End cap airflow is not great, due to material natrually making sort of a seal on the inside. If you like sucktion, this would be a pro. Item price wise is on the cheaper side. Made from quality materials though. Can bonus as a sex pillow with partner. Angle that it holds the Fleshlight is a bit awkward. Has a felt like material on the bottom, so it gribs the bed/floor when using it. I think this thing would be really cool mounted to a wall.

Meiki If you make a mess, not so easy to clean. Use a washcloth with warm water, and blot away any mess immediately. End cap airflow is not a problem due to material not being airtight. Con would be making a mess inside, and trying to keep it clean. I find this not a problem though, mostly using it in upright positions. Item is a bit more expensive compared to Liberator. Plush is made of quality material and put together well. Fleshlight (including case, please use a case) can be fully inserted until its flush. Nice to cuddle. The angle it holds the Fleshlight feels natural, when using it in any position.

I would recommend the Meiki over the Liberator!

Feels more natural. The angle on the Liberator is too odd, and its made only for the missionary position. I just don't ever use the Liberator.