This goes back several years now, to when we all were 22.

I (6’1, brown hair, average build) had a major crush on my classmate, Jenna (barely 5’, blonde, blue eyes, thin but had huge tits and a great ass) but she was dating her long term boyfriend and my roommate, Kyle, so she was off limits. Kyle was a good guy and I didn’t want to be a douche and hit on a girl when she is dating someone. But this is the story of Jenna found out I was on the large side and how it lead to the downfall of their relationship.

We had gone bar hopping one night as a group of friends. Enjoyed some drinks at each bar and conversations started drifting to the more steamy. My FWB, Rachel (5’8, brunette, athletic body), was very sexually open and she asked a particular question that I had a feeling was on purpose.

“Have you ever seen a dick that was as big as a guy in porn?”

Kyle was drunkenly the first to answer, “yeah, maybe one or two in locker rooms.”

Jenna said she hadn’t, and wasn’t convinced they were real. She had only run into guys that were a lot smaller than a porn star.

You saw the color leave Kyle. Clearly that had struck a nerve. We all were quick to notice and quickly changed the topic, but the damage was already done. For the remainder of the night, Kyle wasn’t engaged.

We eventually made it back to our place and Jenna, myself, and Rachel all decided we were going to smoke and keep talking. Kyle decided he just wanted to sleep.

As we were sitting outside, and Jenna randomly said, “You two never answered about seeing a big dick in real life.”

Rachel, who had been with her fair share of guys, said, “Yeah, maybe 2 or 3.”

“Really? How big was the biggest?” Jenna asked almost immediately. Super intrigued.

“Oh, longest was about this long” her hands weren’t more than 8 inches apart, “and the thickest I couldn’t even wrap my hand around.”

“There is no way. You couldn’t close your hand!?” Jenna was clearly flush as she asked.

Rachel turned to me and said, “Oh yeah! Josh can prove it if you want.”

Both Jenna and I asked, “what do you mean?” In such unison that we sounded like the Scooby Doo gang.

Rachel looked at me with a quizzical expression,“Josh, you have to be kidding!? You are the thickest I have been with. Did you seriously not know you were thick?”

I didn’t know how to respond. I honestly had never paid attention and honestly, I thought it looked small.

Rachel kept going, “dude, you are thick. Why do you think we need so much lube? I am tight but damn, I gotta stretch a lot to fit you in. I have told you I feel sore the next day, like come on, you had to have known.”

“I really, truly, honestly had no idea.” I responded.

During this time, Jenna was fixated on me. When I turned to look back at her she quickly looked away as to try and make it look like she wasn’t, but I knew.

“Well, there you have it then. Now you know. Do with it what you will.” Rachel jeered.

The conversation went back to normal and after we finished the bowl, we all went inside and went to bed. I will say, Rachel and I fucked like rabbits that night, but that is a story for a different night.

Over the next few weeks, Kyle and Jenna kept getting into fights in our apartment. Kyle ultimately ended up breaking up with Jenna. He had told me it was because they had too many differences.

Rachel had later learned from Jenna that Kyle couldn’t get over that she slipped up and called him small.

She also told her that Jenna couldn’t stop thinking about big dicks since our conversation. Jenna said she was going to fuck biggest dick she could find. Rachel was pretty sure Jenna meant me, but I will cover that next time. One positive is I now know my cock is at least somewhat big at 7x6.