Part 40

As I released into Natalie, our moans echoed off the tile around us and mingled in the confined space in a way that only heightened what was already an intense experience. This might have been the hardest I had ever climaxed, as well as the loudest I had ever allowed my sounds of pleasure to get with a girl.

Part of it was probably the resonance of the shower, as well as the fact that Jessica and I had to keep it down when fucking in a dorm room, but that logic only worked for the audible side of things. In terms of the physical, the sensations of fucking Natalie like this were amazing, and I was determined to ride that wave for as long as I could as I thrusted again and again and again.

Like always, Natalie was the perfect partner. She matched my rhythm every step of the way, rocking her hips to draw out as much passion as possible from me. Despite the receiving position she was in, she played an active role the entire time with her reactions and her movements, keeping the energy up until she had coaxed out and taken every last drop I had to give.

At this point, I didn’t care if she was going out of her way to be the best partner I ever had or if she was just that gifted where intimacy was involved. Either way, it felt too good to think about much of anything while I was caught up in it all.

“Fuck,” I groaned, lightly resting my forehead against the back of her head as I caught my breath. Based on her moans and whines along the way, Natalie should have been the one who was totally spent at this point, but I ended up being pretty exhausted as well. The long drive, the emotional roller coaster since the younger girl arrived, and now this latest experience with her. Now that I had a bit of clarity, it was starting to feel like this whole Natalie thing would be easier to deal with after a full night’s rest.

She hummed a contented sigh and let me come down for a few seconds before shifting forward and separating the two of us down there. Then, graceful as ever, she slowly swiveled on her heel to face me and placed her hands on my shoulders. Looking up at me with the deep eyes that never failed to capture my attention, she quietly suggested, “Kiss me?”

That was all it took. Whether it was exactly at this moment, or if it was just now hitting me, something had changed between us. I didn’t like Natalie or anything like that, but I also wasn’t trying to distance myself from her. Not even when my mind was more clear, and after we had finished what was supposed to be the last sexual act she had promised me.

As we stared at each other in the steamy shower, there was an unspoken desire hanging in the air. Both in her eyes, and in mine. Barely thinking about it, I leaned in and locked lips with her. I did so again and again and again, until we were tangled up in each others’ arms and completely out of breath. It didn’t take much, considering we were both already a bit winded from everything before.

By the time we were done, the cascading water was starting to feel a bit lukewarm. Maybe we just hadn’t turned up the heat in a while, or the water heater couldn’t keep up any more. Either way, I didn’t have the stamina for another round. I wasn’t sure where to go from here, either. I hadn’t forgotten who Natalie was or why we shouldn’t be in here together; at the same time, I wanted her. Even if it was wrong, or made me a horrible person. Against all odds, she had managed to seduce me to the point where I wanted to have a conversation that didn’t revolve around us ending whatever this was.

Natalie decided what was next, no doubt upon feeling the temperature as the gentle passion subsided. Pressing into me, making sure I couldn’t ignore her bare body against mine, she murmured in my ear. “Go get ready for bed. I’ll be out in a minute.” It was more seductive than bossy; she also managed the teasing lilt even when her voice was barely louder than a whisper. With that, she stepped back and gave me a flirty smirk, letting me check out her naked self again.

Just because I had accepted that I was into her beyond what I had originally justified as a horny mistake or two thanks to Natalie’s shameless advances didn’t mean that she wasn’t a brat. Although that was turning into part of her ‘charm’ at this point, considering the buttons she was learning how to push. “Take as long as you want,” I replied. It’s the first thing I thought of, and would hopefully serve to show her that I wasn’t wrapped around her finger or anything like that.

Leaving Natalie to scrub down after I fucked her like that, I stepped out of the shower and made short work of drying off and pulling my clothes back on. While I was still in the bathroom, I brushed my teeth as well. Now that I was settling back into reality, I finally started thinking about Jessica again. As in, what if she was standing on the other side of the bathroom door with her arms crossed, waiting for me to emerge? Natalie and I really hadn’t been that quiet. Although I knew Jess pretty well, and I’m pretty sure she would opt to storm into the bathroom and catch us in the act, rather than taking a more dramatic approach.

Only one way to find out. Once I was done with my toothbrush, I had nothing else to busy myself with while Natalie was still rinsing off. Ripping off the potential bandaid, though mostly praying that Jessica was fast asleep down the hall, I opened the door.

Check out my website: www.ladyluciastories.com