So I signed up for the 6th Man plan (total $6 after shipping for 4 5ml bottles). I chose 2 flavors, and the other 2 are "Mystery Flavors."

The flavors I chose:

Fuzzy Navel - VERY accurate, almost exactly like the cocktail! Orange Bars - It's like an inside-out Dreamsicle. Very light vanilla cream at the start, with a (slightly artificial) bold orange finish. Quite nice, actually.

The "Mystery Flavors":

The "clear" mystery flavor smells like artificial strawberry (wife says it smells like something called "bubble tea"), and tastes like bubble gum. The slightly darker mystery flavor smells like a pastry, but tastes like cherries and cream (unusual combination, but very interesting).

These were all tried straight out of the mail, with the only steeping done courtesy of the USPS.

Overall, I liked what I got, and think I'll be sticking with the Club for a few months at least.