Chats only please. 😋 Also, no character references. We will play as ourselves only
The Prompt:
I’ve been dating your older sister, Lily (26), for a few years now. If we aren’t officially, we are practically engaged already. Your family likes me a lot and I get along great with everyone, especially you. Now, it’s never been anything crazy. You’ve always been respectful of my relationship with your sister. Besides, you’ve had boyfriends and girlfriends throughout the years and I always have been there to give good advice, kinda like an older brother.Since the pandemic hit your sister and I pretty hard, the two of us (mostly her) decided it would be a good idea to move back into your parents’ house while I get back on my feet. It should be noted that both your parents and your sister work in a hospital, so they are considered essential workers. You, just recently having turned 18, didn’t have a job, and I worked from home. Meaning we were spending a ton of time together lately.I don’t know when it started really, you catching me staring at you while you hang out by the pool in your little bikini, offering to give you, “back massages” while your sister isn’t home, flirting with you more and more and you’re pretty sure you even caught me with your panties the other day in the laundry room. Ah well, it could be innocent. I mean, it’s not like I ever tried anything with you … yet.
The Options:
A) I’ve wanted this for a while. All the times you thought I was just being nice, were actually just excuses for me to get close to you anyway I could. Maybe I even date your sister just to be around you. Maybe I didn’t even know she had a younger sister at first, but once we met, I couldn’t help but fantasize naughty things. Now that we are alone all the time it’s time to make a move 😈
B) I only just started to look at you that way. I always looked at you like an innocent good girl, the sweet younger sister to my bossy girlfriend. Until one day when I came across your OnlyFans page. Of course I signed up under a fake name so you wouldn’t know, but the secret will come out eventually 😉
C) I never intended on getting caught. Like I said previously, you caught me with your panties the other day. What you didn’t know was that I made it a habit to steal your panties, jerk off with them, and then clean them so I wouldn’t get caught. I’ve been doing this at least since I’ve moved in, maybe even longer. Well one day when you were supposed to be at your best friend’s house, I thought it would be a good time to do my dirty little routine. What I didn’t expect was you to walk in on me doing it in your room. 😏
D) I couldn’t have planned it. One evening, in the middle of the night when the house is asleep, I wake up for some water. It just so happens that you also had the same thought. We obviously bump into each other and end up staying up talking. Well one thing leads to another and…let’s just say I snuck back into bed 5 minutes before your sister woke up for work, leaving you in your room with a hot creampie 😇
Subreddit
Post Details
- Posted
- 1 year ago
- Reddit URL
- View post on reddit.com
- External URL
- reddit.com/r/dirtypenpal...