I know this scenario has played out plenty of times, but this one is a little different. My wife (30) and I (34) have been in an on again off again cuckolding relationship for about ten years, and have been out of it for a little while. She’s been sort of hesitant to do humiliation or have me in the room in the past, though we have had some hot encounters like that, so this time she wanted to start things off slow and try to find a relatively vanilla third to have an MFM threesome with.

We looked through the apps until we found a guy - tall, skinny, hung, and seemed pretty chill. He was also really into anal, which my wife loves but not with my cock - she likes something big and girthy in her ass.

We met up with him for a drink and hit it off - he was nice and normal and we didn’t say anything about cuckolding - it was just a standard threesome situation. We all clicked so we decided to go back to his place.

After some small talk we got to business - we all got on his couch (her in between us) and she started making out with him. She climbed ontop of him and they made out passionately, and then he started removing her clothes - exposing her big natural tits and huge athletic toned ass and shaved pussy. I could see it was already glimmering with wetness.

She got off his lap and told us to get naked too. I pulled down my pants to expose my cock and looked over to see that his looked way bigger than his pics - mine is about 5” and a little on the thin side, while his stood erect at probably 8” and very thick. She knelt down and started slowly and passionately sucking his cock while I jerked mine to keep it hard. She spent probably two strokes sucking mine and then stopped and looked at me and said “sorry I can’t concentrate on yours right now” with a light laugh and went back to his massive cock. I could tell he was a little confused but was enjoying himself.

I got behind her and asked if she wanted me to fuck her so to ensure we were still on the same page about the threesome. She didn’t bother answering so I slid into her soaking wet pussy from behind, immediately aware that I wouldn’t be able to last very long. It didn’t matter, because after a few strokes she wiggled her ass away from me and said “okay I need him to fuck me now.”

We moved to the bedroom and I got in position in front of her so she could suck me while he fucked her but she pushed me away and said “maybe you should sit this one out.”

I could see him laugh lightly as I dutifully knelt on the floor by the bed to watch. He pushed into her from behind, taking time as she moaned and told him how big he was and how tight of a squeeze it was. Eventually he managed to get the entire length into her and after some slow thrusting he picked up speed and began to fuck her hard. She was moaning so loud and kept telling him how big he was and how good it felt, making me feel like a little bitch on my knees watching.

They switched to missionary for a bit and he pounded her pussy with her legs up, making her cum HARD. Then he switched to her asshole, slowly at first and then hard again, before switching to doggy and fucking her ass hard in front of me, making her cum again. He pulled out and came on her face, covering her in his cum. They both collapsed on the bed in a sweaty pile, forgetting I was there.

When I made a move towards the bed she said I could fuck her now - which was a little intimidating after having watched this guy just fuck the shit out of her for probably 30 minutes.

I of course lasted about 2 minutes in her stretched out pussy, even more humiliating since she barely seemed to notice and another man who just made her cum twice on his far bigger cock was watching.

She rolled over in to his arms and said “you have the greatest dick in the world” as he let out a confident laugh and I felt my face burning in embarrassment.

We talked a bit more and he asked about our dynamic and was very interested as he knew nothing about cuckolding, but said he found it really hot to dominate my wife in front of me.

We ended up losing track of him afterwards, but it made for a super fun evening