My first attempt at storytelling, please be patient…

My girlfriend and I have been together over 2 years, she’s a funny but shy, girl next door type. She doesn’t have the attitude that she’s the hottest chick on the planet, but she is the perfect type for me. She’s thick in the right places, but doesn’t flaunt it. Me, I’m average build and laid back. I was a bull for quite a few couples before we met, but I’ve started to have feelings about trying another role lately…

Over time, my girl has started to open up more sexually with me from her innocent beginnings. She’s told me about her past experiences and that I’m the biggest she’s had (I believe her lol). She had started teasing me with nude snaps, and eventually we made a few videos of her sucking my cock. The more I watched the video, the more I got turned on at the idea of watching it live… and not just from my usual pov…

One day we were getting into our deeper fantasies and she said she had wanted to try being tied up. When it came to my turn I was nervous to bring it up since I felt like mine was a little more out there but we had both agreed that it was a no judgement zone. I eventually gathered enough courage to tell her I wanted to try a threesome with her… with another guy. It’s not the easiest thing to explain that being straight, I’d want to have another guy join us in the bedroom. But since we were being completely open, I confessed to her that I feel like it would be hot to see her suck another guys cock, especially if he was bigger than I am.

She took it well and joked about having to try everything once (or twice). Which set my mind racing picturing the possibility of us moving forward with this. Over the next few months it came up occasionally with us talking about options and how to get started. She didn’t want to pick the guy, and liked the idea of it being somewhat unexpected, so it felt spontaneous. I did some searching on reddit and another site, and chatted with a few guys. Eventually I felt comfortable enough with one guy that he would be respectful and a good fit.

One night we were having some drinks around the fire pit and I mentioned that I had invited a friend over to join us. We have company over regularly so a new friend wasn’t out of the ordinary. I heard a car door and opened the gate to greet our guest. I introduced them to each other and offered him a drink. I returned to find they had begun some small talk and made it through the awkward beginning of first meets. We sat around the fire for awhile until I made the suggestion to move our conversation into the hot tub. They both agreed and she went inside to get ready. I was getting the hot tub set up when she opened the door and came out in her modest black bikini, asking our guest if he had something to change into. He laughed and said that he didn’t realize that this was part of the plan. My girlfriend offered to grab a pair of my shorts for him, but he politely declined saying it wouldn’t be necessary and he would just go in his boxers, as he started to strip down. I started to undress too, and said “fuck it, let’s just go naked.” I dropped my clothes and climbed into the hot tub. She laughed, and yelled “babe!”

Our guest laughed and said “do you mind?” She held her eyes and turned around, giggling. I watched as he dropped his boxers and his thick cock flopped out. I’m over 7 inches but this guy even impressed me. I told her she could look now, and she turned around as he was half way into the tub. She turned red and said “okay I was not expecting that.” I asked if she was going to join us, and she reached behind her back, untying her bikini top. She pulled it over her head revealing her pale DD tits. She looked at both of us and rolled her eyes as she untied her bottoms as well. Her brunette bush was on full display while she walked over and climbed in to join us. We sipped our drinks and had normal conversation for a little while, until our guest offered to grab some more drinks. He stood up across from us, and his cock caught both of our attention. He went inside, and she whispers to me “did you see his penis?” I laughed and told her it would be pretty hard to miss. I asked her if she was impressed, and her response was “I mean…”

After a minute he came back, and again dangled his cock in front of us as he stood before sitting down. I told him jokingly that I think he’s showing that thing off on purpose. He laughed and said “I don’t know what you’re talking about.” My girlfriend was starting to become more confident in the situation and chimed in “ok so I don’t think I’ve ever complimented a penis before but… nice penis.” We all laughed, and I felt the butterflies in my stomach hearing her talk about another guy’s cock.

I reached my arm around her and whispered in her ear, “you’re naughty tonight…” She bit her lip and took a sip of her drink. We continued trying to make vanilla conversation but you could feel the sexual tension in the air. I was starting to get a little too wrinkled so I suggested that we head inside to get dried off. We all stepped out, and I caught her and him taking peeks at each other’s dripping wet bodies. We wrapped up in towels and headed up to the house…

To be continued…