So I (M23) was invited to a movie night by my friend “Jessica” (F24) and her cousin “Amy” (F24) during the tail end of another mutual friend’s graduation party, and Amy offered to host. I agreed rather than staying and hanging with the boys. To be completely honest, I did this for the plot.

Jessica and I have known each other since high school. She is physically attractive but is kinda ditzy and not my type, but she’s cool and helps me with dating sometimes. Amy, her cousin who she’s started to intertwine more into our wider friend group, I’ve always had a thing for. Jessica knows this too, and has tried to set me up with Amy in the past with albeit with little success, so I backed off her for the time being.

Amy is the small petite church girl type on her exterior, regularly wearing modest, flowery, loose dresses and is exceptionally attractive and fit with a down to earth personality. You’d assume she’s completely innocent, but Jessica has told me some of Amy’s “hoe stories” and she apparently is very well experienced, which has only caused me to fantasize about her even more.

We arrived at Amy’s place around 11:30PM. Amy lets us inside and we all sat on her living room couch while Jessica picked out an interesting looking romcom for us all to watch. We were the only ones in the house. I sat on the adjacent single seat portion while they sat together on the longer side of the L shaped couch. A few minutes after the movie started, Amy went to change out of her dress and into some considerably tight-fitting pink PJ’s. I’ve never seen Amy in clothes that weren’t either a dress or a blouse and jeans before, and in these PJs you could see the outline of her panties hugging her ass as well as the rest of her modest curves being comfortably complimented. I tried not to stare too obviously out of respect, but my eyes couldn’t help but wander.

As the movie went on, Amy alternated between a myriad of positions, including sitting widely spread-legged with her torso facing me and having her bare feet resting on Jessica’s lap also facing towards me. I’m not a foot guy, but damn did she have some pretty looking feet. She would also sometimes fidget her hand by stretching out her PJ pants revealing her grey panties underneath. My mind was racing, but the alcohol I had at our friend’s grad party kept me from pitching a full tent. My gaze alternated between the movie and at Amy’s body and I was enjoying every second of it.

Jessica has confessed to me in the past that she considered herself good at giving head to guys, saying verbatim that she has that “Gawk Gawk 9000”. Despite me seeing her in a completely platonic fashion, the situation at hand lead to me fantasize about a threesome with them both, particularly where Jessica would suck me off on that couch while I would eat out Amy as the movie went on. At that point I knew I was down bad.

After the movie ended, Jessica and I said our goodbyes to Amy, picking up after ourselves and then exhanging hugs. Jessica dropped me off at my place and then headed home herself as we had all carpooled to the party. As soon as I was in the comfort of my bed, I had to get a few off before I would be able to sleep.

Hopefully we all can do another movie night soon 🤞