Percy- copies half his recipe from Annabeth ~ cake comes out tasty, but it would serve better as construction material ~ chocolate

Annabeth- somehow manages to dig up ancient cake recipes on deadalus' laptop ~ best cake of the bunch, 10/10 ~ vanilla

Frank- finds a decent recipe on wiki and applies some basic tricks to improve it ~ accidentally knocks the whole bowl of sugar into his batter ~ VERY sweet Carrot cake

Hazel~ Rubies don't count as Garnish, they aren't edible! ~ can make a cake out of anything, she's rocking with that great depression recipe ingenuity ~ red velvet

Leo~ who knows where the recipe came from ~ very moist, and dense, tied with Annabeth as far as taste, texture, and physical appeal go ~ stains your teeth pink for a week lol ~ chocolate

Piper~ No, the Cake doesn't HAVE to be shaped like a picture perfect silhouette of Jason with frosted in details, but it doesn't have to NOT be that ~ ice cream cake

Jason~ sneezes and a perfectly formed cake descends from the heavens in a golden chariot ~ vanilla ~ there's also a razor blade or 2 imbedded inside it?