Coming soon - Get a detailed view of why an account is flagged as spam!
view details

This post has been de-listed

It is no longer included in search results and normal feeds (front page, hot posts, subreddit posts, etc). It remains visible only via the author's post history.

1,295
Requesting your honest opinion! What do you think of this design?
Post Body

What do you think about this type of bookshelf design for a home?

I think it would make a beautiful backdrop for my TikTok videos I make rating books.

We did not build this bookshelf but we got it from another FB wood working group and talked to the couple that made it. We’re in love with it but see how the lumber is think and might not be as sexy in person as in the pictures.

Images
Comments
[not loaded or deleted]

I can see how cats would love it, lol! We have two! One acts like a dog! Yours looks awesome!

[not loaded or deleted]

Ha ha! That’s an awesome comment! Kept me reading to figure out how I lost a point! It’s made is 2x10” pine so stacking two 2” thick ends together will make us loose a lot of space when it all adds up. At the same time the bulkiness and odd shaped boxes add an appeal too it I can’t put my finger on but I like it.

[not loaded or deleted]

I want another color but my husband it wants black. He said it will make the books stand out and not bleed into the background. I don’t know though. I bet if I was more creative we could make other colors look good.

[not loaded or deleted]

We think so too! It’s made is 2”x10” pine so when the boxes are stacked it’s roughly 4” think on each end. That will make us loose a lot of spanked but the bulkiness is it is also attractive. Hard to put a finger in it.

[not loaded or deleted]

It will be made of white pine. We’re not going to use any exotics and hard wood with this. We have a lot of things we want to display too a long with the books so we think it will add to it more. My husband has a lot of cool items from the war and from being a coal miner. I think they would look cool displayed.

[not loaded or deleted]

We get it! We like it but don’t but do! That makes no sense but it is what it is, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

All good points!

[not loaded or deleted]

Awesome! Thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]

Nothing wrong with being different sometimes, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah, it does look cool! Thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah, I think it leaves lots of options to display books in different ways!

[not loaded or deleted]

Awesome! Thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]

All good points! I’m impressed you read other comments too! The best thing is it’s not too expensive to replace. We want to have the Amish make us something but that’s after the kids are older.

[not loaded or deleted]

We like darker things. Idk why. I think because it hides dust better, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah, it’s pretty cool! Can’t put a finger on it at times but something about it is neat! I think it makes a cool backdrop too for pictures and videos. We think it is cool to display things on this way too.

[not loaded or deleted]

All facts! Yeah, we would prefer a hard wood but we’re not sure if we will want to change this out or keep it. It’s mainly so the kids don’t break anything else that’s expensive. One already broke the main water line below the cut off this year, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

We thought about that too because of our kids! Then we thought we would try to start stuffing stuff in them so changed our minds.

[not loaded or deleted]

Cool! Thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]

Thank you! We’ve not built ours yet! This is what a couple made that we’ve talked to. They’re our inspiration to make ours! We wanted feedback before we invested time and money.

[not loaded or deleted]

It does look pretty cool! Thank you for your feedback! I did not know you could post pictures with comments! Interesting!

[not loaded or deleted]

That’s pretty cool of you to say! Thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]

Heck yeah! I appreciate that feedback!

[not loaded or deleted]

Thank you! I really appreciate your feedback! It looks so different. That’s what we like about it. Traditional would hold more books but we wanted something folks would come over to see and talk about.

[not loaded or deleted]

Thank you! We dig it too!

[not loaded or deleted]

That’s awesome!

[not loaded or deleted]

Thank you for your feedback! Awesome!

[not loaded or deleted]

We think the same thing! Thank you for your feedback!

[not loaded or deleted]

We’re thinking so too!

[not loaded or deleted]

Awesome! Thank you for the feedback!

[not loaded or deleted]

We will post pictures once we get it all done! Hopefully it turned out great!

[not loaded or deleted]

Oh they are definitely heavy! A bookshelf should match its person and I’m a little thick! Jk! Just kidding trying to be funny, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

We’re going to build it on multiple walls lol. We think it will help us display a lot of our stuff on the books.

[not loaded or deleted]

No, not at all! I think the selves will help hold the second floor up too, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

It’s made of white pine. We’re not using hardwood or exotics. We wanted something that would be between $300 to $500 and that we could rate out later if we wanted to change directions a few years down the road.

[not loaded or deleted]

Our basement furniture is rustic farm so I think this fits it. We wanted to work on making furniture that would last with kids vs something made of compressed materials from a store. The white pine furniture is taking hits from kids like a champ! We think the bookshelves will do the same and look good doing it.

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah, the roughness adds a little to it. Makes it a little rustic. Goes with the farm style rustic we have in the basement.

[not loaded or deleted]

Ha ha! I told my husband I want a small library in the basement and I want one wall of bookshelves in our bedroom! When our kids move out I want a bedroom made into a room of books! The question is are all our kids going to move out or not.. We are thinking one will stay lol. Probably momma’s boy!

[not loaded or deleted]

I think it’s the unique look and bulkiness of it all that makes it different and beautiful at the same time. Maybe not the best use of space but something about it is cool.

[not loaded or deleted]

Thank you! We love hearing that!

[not loaded or deleted]

It does not match all of them but it gives me another reason to buy more books to fit those spaces. There is a secret plan to this getting me more books lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah I’m not at 1200 yet lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

It would have a been nice!

[not loaded or deleted]

I’ve read most of mine. That’s why we buy boos every two weeks. I review books on TikTok. I’m nothing special. I just do it because I enjoy it.

[not loaded or deleted]

It is! It looks so cool! The different size boxes like blow my mind.

[not loaded or deleted]

It’s beautiful for sure! Maybe too thick where the 2x10 boxes meet up but something about it is catchy!

[not loaded or deleted]

We will! 100%! This is really important to me and that’s why my husband is putting a lot of thought into it.

[not loaded or deleted]

I think we’re going to go for it! All the feedback we’re getting from here from people we don’t know is more concrete that it will be nice vs our own thoughts. If that makes sense.

[not loaded or deleted]

We did not build this own. We talked to the guy that build it in a FB woodworking group and fell in love with it. My husband is nervous to comment to it just because he wants to make something people will some over and be impressed by. He thinks this will be it but wanted other peoples feed back before we invest money and time into it.

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah, I saw I said put a finger in it vs put a finger on it! This dang app will not let you go back and edit it after you hit reply so I had to go with it, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

We agree! Thanks!

[not loaded or deleted]

That’s awesome! Thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]

I have so many different series and book styles! The books you put together and they make faces is my favorite! For those that don’t want to separate/OCD organize, this could be a problem, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]
[not loaded or deleted]

We totally get that! Yes, it is thick.

[not loaded or deleted]

If we have doors, we will end up stuffing things in to hide them! Oh do you mean clear glass doors? I get that!

[not loaded or deleted]

Heck yeah! Thanks!

[not loaded or deleted]

Awesome! Thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]

We think so too! It looks so cool!

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah we’re definitely interested in lighting!

[not loaded or deleted]
[not loaded or deleted]
[not loaded or deleted]

The top floor we have painted wood furniture. Downstairs were bigger fans of stained items. Seems to hide kids dirty finger prints more.

[not loaded or deleted]

That’s awesome! We love puzzles at our house btw!

[not loaded or deleted]
[not loaded or deleted]

Goth girl at heart here!

[not loaded or deleted]

Awesome!!!! Yeah, I get in some places it looks nice but in other home it would not.

[not loaded or deleted]

I get that! Our house is chaotic with four kids, lol! It all goes together, lol! Jk!

[not loaded or deleted]

That’s awesome! Thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]

Exactly!!! Yeah, this is basically the crate idea with large lumber.

[not loaded or deleted]

We wish you luck on it! Remember it all really boils down to if you like it or not!

[not loaded or deleted]

Ha ha! Facts!

[not loaded or deleted]

It’s crazy watching her eat peppers! I can’t imagine seeing a cat eat a tomato, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah, there is something about it that’s cool. Hard to put a finger in it sometimes.

[not loaded or deleted]

It does look pretty cool!

[not loaded or deleted]

Not buying it. We’re making it. It’s not costing us that much because we’re using white pine 2x10’s and planning them down ourselves and doing the work. That way if we want to rip them back out in a year or two we can and we’re only out $500 or less of material and time. Plus, it will be able to take abuse from our kids vs store bought things.

[not loaded or deleted]
[not loaded or deleted]

Yours is beautiful!

[not loaded or deleted]

Ha ha! It’s taken a lot of begging on my part to get my husband to do it, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]
[not loaded or deleted]
[not loaded or deleted]

Awesome, thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]
[not loaded or deleted]

Awesome! Thank you for the feedback!

[not loaded or deleted]

We wanted to something that can take damage from kids and if it gets too messed up we could burn it and move on. Our furniture in the basement is a farm rustic homemade type. It looks better than you might be picturing in your head. He uses bench top jointer etc to clean up the edges. All stuff idk. I just sit there and look pretty and hold things lol.

[not loaded or deleted]

I’m we’ve not thought about light grey before!

[not loaded or deleted]

All good points btw! I don’t want you to think I’m arguing! We’ve been tearing it up and down trying to decide to commit to it. We like the different size boxes because we have different size books and stuff to display. It’s made of white pine so if we rip it out in two years we will not loose more than $500.

I appreciate the feedback! I forgot to add it to the original discussion but I did a few times in comments. It’s made of 2”x10” white pine so it’s not to expensive and not a issue to replace at a later date if we want too. We have kids and the pine seems to take abuse better than compressed shelves from stores. It matches our rustic farm look in the basement.

These pictures are from someone we talked to in a wood working FB group. They got their inspiration from someone else and were getting ours from them.

We definitely want a darker stain. Our walls are blue and it would match the loose we have going on. We’ve considered painting it white and staining the trim. Not 100% sold on either option yet. Leaning more to all stain though.

It is thick. There is a unique look from it and because it’s not refined we find something attractive about it. We’re debating with ours running it through our bench planner first to make the edges cleaner. Don’t know if it will take away from the rustic look yet or not. We’re going to make two models of each way to see.

[not loaded or deleted]

It’s definitely unique! Thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah, Pinterest is where the couple we got this from saw it first. They made this at their house and we fell in love with it too. Well we go back and forth about things. It makes more sense to have traditional bookshelves but these are great to display things on and it looks rugged/rustic. For our finished basement it would look great and match the already dented furniture from young children, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]
[not loaded or deleted]

Thank you! I really appreciate hearing that!

[not loaded or deleted]

Ha ha! Well, we keep having kids so no one is moving in anytime soon, lol! We’re waiting for one to move out so we can turn their room into a library, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

We wish we understood lighting! I know it’s probably so simple to most people but we don’t feel confident it anything we pick. My husband wants our bottom floor to have more colored lighting but we just suck at it lol. I agree though. The right lighting will look amazing!

[not loaded or deleted]

Sounds beautiful! Yeah, the Army moved us here before he retired. We wanted to go to Montana. The Army said yes on a Friday and Monday morning we had orders to Indiana, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

We totally get it! That’s why it’s been hard to say yes to it! We would have more room with traditional shelf’s but with these we can display things if different sizes better. It’s something different that could be something to talk about when guest come over. If we don’t like it, we can always rip it out and burn it, lol.

[not loaded or deleted]

I love having hot chocolate, a blanket, and a good book! It’s my favorite thing since we moved to Indiana from Texas. I love the snow as long as I’m inside and my husband gets the firewood, lol.

[not loaded or deleted]

Once they are nailed down I don’t think we will adjust them really. I get what you’re saying though and I agree!

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah the books change the entire dynamic of it!

[not loaded or deleted]

You did say it twice, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

That’s for sure! We would have to burn it in sections, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

You have to plan it all out of you could have gaps and you don’t want that to happen.

[not loaded or deleted]

That’s awesome! Thank you!

[not loaded or deleted]

Yeah we definitely run test before we stain, paint, sand, etc. Totally get what you’re saying!

[not loaded or deleted]

My husband said if it looks too bad, 2x10” white pine is not that expensive so we could throw it out and burn it later on and he will not cry as much about it, lol. I think it’s worth a shot to try.

[not loaded or deleted]

We like how it makes it stand out! This is not our house though. It’s the couples house that help give us the idea from something they seen previously. Our house had blue walls.

[not loaded or deleted]

I totally get that. It’s not as clean as most custom made bookshelves but we like the unique look of it. We want something that a guest would stop and say, that’s different and I like it. Something to talk about and finally be cool for once in our life, lol!

[not loaded or deleted]

We have wood paneling wall that are painted blue in our finished basement. Not our choice but how we bought the house. We like the blue but not the panels. He thinks mounting a black flat panel on bookshelf’s like in the picture will help hide the ones that make up the wall and make it have a smoother look.

[not loaded or deleted]

It really is isn’t it! Very eye catching.

[not loaded or deleted]

Those books and the bookshelf belong to a couple we talked to in a FB woodworking group. We loved their idea that they got from somewhere else. We posted here to get feedback from people we don’t know to see if we build it would it be a conversation peace or look too simple. I have over 300 books so we need bookshelf’s, lol! We just wanted feedback before we invest money and time.

[not loaded or deleted]

I think the difference size squares make it really cool to look at!

[not loaded or deleted]

Awesome! Thank you!

Author
Account Strength
70%
Account Age
2 years
Verified Email
Yes
Verified Flair
No
Total Karma
2,020
Link Karma
1,493
Comment Karma
527
Profile updated: 5 days ago
Posts updated: 1 week ago

Subreddit

Post Details

We try to extract some basic information from the post title. This is not always successful or accurate, please use your best judgement and compare these values to the post title and body for confirmation.
Posted
3 months ago