I think this might lead to a more constructive discussion here, considering how this place is much smaller, etc.
Now that the blocksize debate is back in the spotlight again, we all need to be reminded:
A hardfork is difficult to do under any circumstances.
That said, I don't believe that we'll need "100%" as some... ahem respectable folks in the community claim; Bitcoin is nothing without its economy and ecosystem, and what's essential to a fork is that it has the overwhelming majority of economic activity. Assuming the miners are not malicious, they will follow - and they will be onboard sooner and make the process less destructive if they see the overwhelming majority sooner.
Therefore, I propose we compile a checklist of major parties that we need to convince, in order to gain momentum on this. This list will become very useful once /u/gavinandresen, /u/mike_hearn and /u/jgarzik finish their version of 0.11 / 0.11A XT for review.
I'll start with a list. The list is only a starter from my limited knowledge, so feel free to suggest changes:
Exchanges and Payment Processors
- Coinbase
- Bitpay
- Huobi
- Circle
- Bitfinex
- Liberty X
- Bitstamp
- Kraken
- itbit
- Localbitcoins (escrow)
- Paxful (escrow)
- Bitquick.co (escrow)
- 100bit.co.in (escrow)
- Square
- Braintree(?)
- Bitnet (?)
- OkCoin(?)
- BTC-e (?)
- Other local exchanges (?)
Major services/merchants that use a node
Note: Merchants that use payment processors will switch if payment processors are on board.
- Shapeshift
- Purse
- BTCJam
- BLC
- Tradeblock(?)
- Blocktrail(?)
- Darknet markets (?)
- Openbazaar(?)
Major mining pools
Unfortunately Eligius can never be convinced. What a shame. =\
- F2Pool
- BTCChina
- AntPool
- BW
- 21 inc.
- KnC
- BitFury
- Slush
- P2Pool (?)
Wallets
Greenaddress is unlikely to be convinced.
- Electrum
- Armory
- Mycelium
Schildbach/Breadwallet(?)/anything that depends on bitcoinjwill follow the longest chain, so irrelevant- Coinkite(?)
- Bitgo
- Xapo
Information website
While not essential to the ecosystem, will probably help a lot in getting the words out and hence building momentum.
- Bitcoin.org(?)
Feel free to suggest additions/changes to the checklist. Let's get a roadmap so that we know what to aim for.
Subreddit
Post Details
- Posted
- 9 years ago
- Reddit URL
- View post on reddit.com
- External URL
- reddit.com/r/bitcoinxt/c...