Coming soon - Get a detailed view of why an account is flagged as spam!
view details

This post has been de-listed (Author was flagged for spam)

It is no longer included in search results and normal feeds (front page, hot posts, subreddit posts, etc). It remains visible only via the author's post history.

22
Some actual bad philosophy...
Post Body

As in bad philosophy with ramifications.

Backstory: I'm currently reading PI. The new(-ish) translation is awesome because it puts the German next to the English. I love that, because it allows someone like me to see that the translators (important, well-known, and respected philosophers all) are not good at their jobs. Thus, in section 134, we have

Let us examine the proposition: "This is how things are."--How can I say that this is the general form of propositions?--It is first and foremost itself a proposition, an English sentence, for it has a subject and a predicate. But how is this sentence applied--that is, in our everyday language.

Compare that to the original German:

Betracheten wir den Satz: "Es verhält sic so und so"--wie kann ich sagen, dies sei die allgemeine Form des Satzes?--Es ist vor allem slebst ein Satx, ein deutscher Satx, denn es hat Subjekt und Prädikat. Wie aber wird dieser Satz angewendet--in undrer alltäglichen Sprache nämlich?

Now, those of you who speak German might notice that the translators changed "deutscher" to "English," but that's not the problem. The issue is that they translated Satz into two different (and philosophically loaded!) terms in the same fucking paragraph! It would be one thing to just translate Satz as proposition, weird and possibly unacceptable (it's like the fifth or sixth meaning my dictionary has, but whatever), but doing so in contrast to the normal translation of sentence totally changes the meaning of the paragraph, makes the point about the relationship between propositions and sentences rather than just about sentences. UGGGGHHHH.

Oh, also, all hail tuna.

Author
Account Strength
0%
Account Age
12 years
Verified Email
No
Verified Flair
No
Total Karma
48,454
Link Karma
2,855
Comment Karma
44,884
Profile updated: 4 months ago
Posts updated: 7 months ago
resident science mist

Subreddit

Post Details

We try to extract some basic information from the post title. This is not always successful or accurate, please use your best judgement and compare these values to the post title and body for confirmation.
Posted
10 years ago