I was looking at r/avesNYC_tix for May 10 Fisher tickets (NYC) for a few days but I couldn't find any there. The face value of ticket was around $70-80. We really wanted to go with my girlfriend and I thought the prices would go even higher over time if we wait longer so I bought 2x for $380 in total on tickpick.com today (April 29).

They confirmed my order, charged my card, but haven't delivered my tickets. They say the online tickets will be delivered on May 9 (the day before the event). I have read many reviews online of people who didn't receive their tickets on time because of last minute cancellations, delivering the wrong tickets, wrong seats, etc. So I really wanted to see the correct tickets on my account to avoid any issues the day before the event to avoid last minute frustrations.

I know the online delivery window is open on Dice for this specific event so I can't see why they can't deliver the tickets to me now instead of waiting the day before the event. I asked for a refund but they refused it.

What do you guys think? How was your tickpick.com experience before? Is this a common experience? Should I try disputing the charge on my credit card?