You voted here (maybe). This is highly official.

Of the 102k members bots on this sub, 60 humans voted.

• For totaling, I used the top 3 scents for each person that were not DQ'ed. Just scents were DQ'ed, not people. We don't actually DQ here (anymore).
• Top scent got 3 points, 2nd 2 points, 3rd 1 point.
• If you just listed one scent, it got 3 points.
• If you posted "in any order", I ignored that comment. You were given a directive. I treated the order you listed them as your stream of thought, and assumed the one you liked most was typed first.

And the top 10....

10 Declaration Grooming - Fake Yellow Light

7 (tie) Chatillon Lux (Declaration Grooming soap) - 1904

7 (tie) House of Mammoth - Alive

7 (tie) Summer Break Soaps - Rope Swing

6 House of Mammoth - Embrace

4 (tie) House of Mammoth - Tobacconist

4 (tie) House of Mammoth - Santa Noir

3 Southern Witchcrafts (scented by Shawn Maher) - Fougere Nemeta

2 House of Mammoth (Declaration Grooming soap) - Cerberus

1 Spearhead (scented by Shawn Maher) - Seaforth! Sea Spice Lime

Additional data points, and thoughts.

• This was not even a competition for the top spot, really. Sea Spice Lime has almost as many points as Cerberus and Fougere Nemeta combined.
• Of the 60 people who voted, over 35 had SSL in their top 3. Universally loved? Future classic, ala Seville, Executive Man, Ghost Town Barber?
• /u/mammothben has 5 of the top 10? How's a facebook artisan take down half a reddit list? This is how.
• Shocking absolutely no one, /u/hawns clocks in with 2 of the top 3, and 3 of the top 10.
• 3 of the top 10 scents are sold in /u/declarationgrooming soap. Which is a pretty good soap, if you haven't heard.

I'm off to buy some Cerberus....