http://imgur.com/IQhm7Yw

It smells exactly like Reef Point's Submariner. Below is the scent description from each makers' site.

Reef Point Submariner:

This is a deep, smooth, rich scent with tonka bean, apple wood, vanilla bourbon, cedar, oak moss, allspice, cardamom, and patchouli

and...

WSP Mahogany:

Mahogany accented with Italian bergamot, apple wood, Tonka bean, patchouli, cedar wood, oak moss, cardamom, vanilla bourbon and allspice.

Almost identical fragrance list, and my nose can seem to pick out any differences.

The formula is definitely different, though. Reef Point is a hard puck (not MFW hard), and WSP is a very soft "croap". No clay listed in the WSP ingredients, but it is present in Reef Point. WSP is a vegan formula, RP is tallow based. Oh, and they both use the same tin and printed paper labels.

I just thought it odd that both vendors' new releases had identical scents. I'm looking forward to trying out the WSP soap in the morning, and if I have time, I may even test lather it tonight.