How to move on from another “ok” experience with a MFM experience?

My wife and I had our second guy over. He was too young for her but he did satisfy her.

His age being 24 was really a problem with any communication. He was well endowed (they all think that’s the only important thing 🤣) and he did make her cum.

He was good with his mouth too.

We are so new we are wondering if we just stay away from these men that young?

We are torn because so much was good but he was completely quiet, didn’t really engage verbally and in the end ruined the experience even though she was sexually satisfied.

Maybe we’re looking for too much. But, we wanted a playful, talkative guy to make it fun.

He basically ended up being a well hung and good fuck.

Very, very forgettable.

Advice on how to better vet these men? We had drinks with him and talked on the phone before our hookup But his personality in the bedroom was just awful.

I know it’s a mixed experience but we wanted playful and we basically got a robot that made her cum.

And he left thinking he was the biggest stud in the world 🤣