After finally being able to watch every episode of the US show so far, I've gone and ranked all the American contestants (except Cluedle-Doo, who I didn't include because he wasn't technically a contestant). I've taken into account every contestant's singing ability, entertainment value, and (if they had multiple performances) consistency from episode to episode.

This is my opinion only. If you don't agree, that's fine...you're welcome to make your own list.

Here we go...

1. Jackass-In-The-Box

2. Beach Ball

3. Phoenix

4. Lips

5. Gremlin

6. White Tiger

7. Knight

8. Raccoon

9. Pineapple

10. Unicorn

11. Ice Cream

12. Hippo

13. Bear

14. Panda

15. Beetle

16. Eagle

17. Deer

18. Ram

19. Penguin

20. Pi-Rat

21. Grandpa Monster

22. Baby

23. Hedgehog

24. Egg

25. Poodle

26. Hydra

27. Armadillo

28. Elephant

29. Milkshake

30. Avocado

31. Dalmatian

32. Octopus

33. Jester

34. Mother Nature

35. Snail

36. Robot

37. Baby Mammoth (RIP)

38. Cyclops

39. Scarecrow

40. Cupcake

41. Swan

42. Llama

43. Giraffe

44. Raven

45. Fortune Teller

46. McTerrier

47. Lemur

48. Skeleton

49. Bulldog

50. Baby Alien

51. Whatchamacallit

52. T-Rex

53. Mummies

54. Squiggly Monster (RIP)

55. Ladybug

56. Alien

57. Taco

58. Venus Flytrap

59. Pufferfish

60. Hamster

61. Mouse

62. Dragon

63. Bride

64. Orca

65. Broccoli

66. Mallard

67. Gopher

68. Miss Monster

69. Crab

70. Space Bunny

71. Sir Bug-A-Boo

72. Black Widow

73. Seashell

74. Flower

75. Tree

76. Frog

77. Maize

78. Robogirl

79. Firefly

80. Kangaroo

81. Astronaut

82. Hummingbird

83. Thingamabob

84. Caterpillar

85. Walrus

86. Banana

87. Snow Owls

88. Jellyfish

89. Banana Split

90. Snowstorm

91. Chameleon

92. Rhino

93. Mermaid

94. Night Angel

95. Robopine

96. Panther

97. Miss Teddy

98. Popcorn

99. Thingamajig

100. Mushroom

101. Kitty

102. Lambs

103. Queen Cobras

104. Butterfly

105. Flamingo

106. Lion

107. Yeti

108. Rabbit

109. Piglet

110. Crocodile

111. Turtle

112. Pepper

113. Prince

114. Serpent

115. Skunk

116. Bee

117. Bull

118. Leopard

119. Russian Dolls

120. Ringmaster

121. Black Swan

122. Queen of Hearts

123. Monster

124. Peacock

125. Seahorse

126. Rottweiler

127. Harp

128. Sun

129. Fox