So to first say yes I know this is controversail opinion wise but my last place I just didn't like them. I just could never get into them and the fact that they kept making more made it worse imo, despite staring incredibly talented people.

Anyways here is my ranking.

1. Starship/Twisted (couldn't pick)
2. A VHS Christmas Carol/VHSCCS
3. Holy Musical B@man!
4. AVPM
5. AVPS
6. Ani: A Parody
7. Firebringer
8. Trail to Oregon!
9. AVPSY
10. Me and My Dick
11. All Hatchetfield Musicals/Shows

I'd like to see what everyone else's rankings are. I've seen a few online and you can see who is usually the newer Starkid fans because most of them, even though they took the time to watch them all, would rank all the Hatchetfields at the top which I just can't comprehend. But that is just me.