Throwback… but the story still gets me excited.
When I was 19, my sister (23) slept with the same man two weeks apart.
I was using her ID to go to a bar one summer when we lived together for 9 weeks. I met this guy that was, honestly out of my league but was so enjoyable and had such a memorable grunt/moan when he came for me.
I remember riding him with my hands on his strong shoulders and I slide him in an out of me until I came, I told him to go on top and in minutes he had me orgasm again and then he came while his hot little moan came out.
Fast forward 2 weeks. My sis texts me a heads up to stay in my room as she is having someone over. When they arrived I could hear them kissing in the entry and he asked if he had been there before. She was like “um no?” I could hear their lips smacking as they made their way down the hall when I heard my door start to slide open. My sister said “no, my room is down the hall”. Ya he’s just drunk I thought. About 20 minutes later I heard the cute little grunt/ moan and knew it had to be him! I later asked my sister if the man she was with had dyed blonde hair and she confirmed. (He was Asian so it stands out). And at that point we knew we slept with the same guy. Might have been 8 years ago but I just found it so hot that we brought back the same guy. He definitely got his share of both sisters.