So, there were a couple of years when my wife and I would have the occasional threesome with another woman. My wife had some rules, as expected, with one of those being I always wore a condom with the other woman. I managed to follow that rule quite judiciously…that is until this one girl, Beth.

Beth was a decade younger than me and very eager to meet both of us and have some fun. It sounded like she had experience with couples and was looking for a couple to become a permanent part of it. We hadn’t progressed that far into the lifestyle, and she was okay with just playing and seeing where things went.

We scheduled to hang out on Sunday morning into the afternoon and met up with her at a nearby coffee place. It didn’t take long until we all agreed to return to our place and play. Throughout our conversation, I would catch little looks from her when my wife wasn’t paying attention. Then, when my wife went to use the restroom, Beth started touching my thigh and rubbing under the table while we continued with mundane chit-chat. She gave my hardening cock a nice squeeze through my jeans as my wife came back, which led to me delaying our departure for a few more minutes before I could stand up.

We got back to our place, and Beth and my wife started making out and undressing each other. I enjoyed watching and stroking. My wife looked at me and gave me our little signal that she wanted me to join in now. The three of us had sex together. If you read the title, you know that’s not what this story is about. This is about me breaking my wife’s primary rule while she was just feet away.

After a few rounds, my wife said she was going to take a shower. Beth and I were still in bed naked, and as soon as the bathroom door closed and the shower turned on, Beth pulled me and started making out with abandon. Her hand was under the sheets stroking me off, and she whispered, “It’s not fair she gets your cum inside her, and I don’t.” I mean, I do believe in equality. Who was I to deny this poor woman? 

I got between her thighs, cock more than ready to go, and slid into Beth completely raw. Her juices soaked my cock immediately. I didn’t think I’d have more in me, but this lady just knew how to get it. She worked her hips back against mine and locked her legs around my waist, showing me how she wasn’t letting me pull out even if I had wanted to. You guess it wasn’t long before that familiar pleasure & pressure built up, and I emptied a nice warm load deep inside this young woman, breaking my wife’s threesome rule. 

Beth was grinning ear to ear, the cat who caught the canary. She got what she wanted, and I had a feeling that was common with her. She whispered, “Your cum feels so good in me, Daddy.” and if it was possible, my cock would have had a stroke. I suggested we exchange phone numbers so that we could chat later. Then, I worked to make sure there’d be no evidence of my rule-breaking.

Beth and I did text quite a bit for the following two months and almost hooked up one-on-one on another day, but it didn’t work out. I follow the rules closely most of the time, but this was one instance where I was pleased to break them.