Why do men like girls using butt plugs so much? I have a 19-year-old neighbor. Our houses are very close together. Sometimes he comes over and asks me to borrow something. It was around 2pm. I was home alone and feeling a little horny. I was using my phone and touching my pussy. I started to get really excited, so I went and put in a butt plug. Because I cum easier when I'm plugged in. I masturbated and came, but I kept using the butt plug. I was wearing a short dress, especially because it was quite hot. I went to my living room and lay down on the couch, using my cell phone. I was lying on my stomach with my legs pointing towards the window. The window was open. Suddenly my neighbor put his head in the window and called my name. On impulse, I got up and sat down. He asked me what that was in my ass. I replied that it was nothing. He asked, "Are you using a butt plug?" I said that it was none of your business, but he kept insisting, asking me to show him. I kept refusing. It got to the point where he offered me $100 to show him, and I still refused. But he kept insisting. I asked him, "If I show you, will you leave?" He replied that he would. I bent over and showed him. He said it was beautiful and that he had never seen a girl using a plug. He asked if he could come in. I closed the window in his face and told him to go home.