So I know I’ve never been “big” but I never imagined I was small. Fast forward to this girl I had been talking to and we are hooking up, things getting heavier between us. Making out led to our clothes coming off, showing that she had a diamond plug in her ass. Well when she saw my cock she went from eager to laughter. She explained that she wanted to be fucked in the ass but her plug is so much bigger than me that I won’t even stretch her out.. I tried to act tough like she had to be lying but when I slowly pulled that plug out it left her gaped wider than my dick could ever be… she still made me slid it in her ass and told me how she couldn’t feel it while laughing.. to make matters worse that was the final straw and I began to spurt ropes of my hot sticky cum prematurely deep in her asshole. She kept giggling, sliding forward then looking back at me wiggling her ass, “clean it up.” Was all she said while holding her asscheeks apart. I spent the next few minutes lapping her asshole till it was all clean and she had me replace the plug. All in all it was a great night and now she calls me her “little guy”