For backstory, my friend lives a while away but when we see each other the sex is 👌🏻. I haven't slept with someone else who has had a dick ever, he's my first and so far only. I've done a lot of exploring with him and trust him completely.

He and I talk about fantasies a lot. One of the nights he had come to visit me, he kept saying he had a surprise for me and seemed really excited for it. He refused to tell me what it was.

Finally, he told me he wanted to tie me up and blindfold me, -legs strapped behind my head and arms bound to them so I was completely spread open and unable to move. This wasnt out of the norm for things we do together or have done in the past, so I had no idea what was coming but knew that wasn't the surprise. After doing so, he said he'd be back. I couldn't see anything but I heard him walk out and head to where my living room was. I was confused, but patient, until I heard him open my sliding patio glass door that leads outside. It was quickly shut again and I heard the lock click. I was on high alert at this point, my senses were heightened and it sounded like two sets of footsteps were headed my way and I heard my friend make a very quiet sushing noise at... somebody??

This is when my brain remembered the conversation he and I had about me possibly fucking his friends, how I'd had a fantasy about anonymous sex and how I'd only do it if I knew it was safe. This is what my brain assumed was happening as I felt someone touch my naked body. The touches were so gentle and exploratory- like it was the first time they had touched me and were scared I would break. It was totally different than how my friend would normally touch me. At that moment I knew that my friend invited someone over and this was someone different.

In an effort to not ruin the fantasy that my friend had clearly set up for me, I layed there and let it progress. I remember being so turned on about the whole thing, so finally when I felt this person pull their dick out I was so nervous but excited. He was rubbing it against me and it was HUGE. This would have only been the second person ever to fuck me so I was so anxious. He was so gentle and slowly worked me up into it. It felt so good, I was blown away and so aroused that it ended up being easy for him to be able to fill me.

That's when things went different, suddenly they weren't gentle and we're so aggressive, fucking me super hard and choking me out. I won't lie and say I wasn't a little scared- but nothing was done outside of my comfort zones/limits, and I had FULL faith in my friend telling this man to stop if he felt it was too far. But just laying there, tied up and being fucked by some random person- I don't think anything has ever turned me on more.

Looking back on it, my brain still struggles with this because I was SO sure it wasn't my friend. It turns out that my friend had schemed the entire thing to trick my brain into thinking it was someone else, from the opening of the door and the sushing out loud, to changing the way he was touching me, to even wearing a cocksleeve to make his dick not feel the same. As I was getting close to cumming, he takes my blindfold off and smirks at me. I swear I don't think anything will ever be hotter than that moment- him sweaty and cocky, fully knowing he just satisfied one of my biggest fantasies without actually putting me in any danger like I wanted. He teased me endlessly after the scene was over and he made sure I was okay. I really thought it wasn't him.

The entire thing was so amazing and thoughtful of him and I needed to share.